ISSUE
: “WHY I want to be a lawyer?!?!”
RULE: The purpose of this blog is to encourage discussion. I am totally aware that my opinions usually vacillate between the cynical and the idealistic, and this is my attempt, before I take the bar, to “come clean.” Thus I subject myself to you for debate. Don’t hold back.

HOLDINGS:

Saturday, August 18, 2012

Unexpecticality


Well, this week has been interesting. Indonesia is a conundrum. I expected nothing to work out the way I planned this summer –but not in the way its turning out. Every moment, I vacillate between despair that I will accomplish nothing and hope that the unexpected might bring me to a fabulous summer of discovery. My site mate and I discuss daily the current PC term for this part of the world, if it is even a part, rather than just itself –Indonesia. “Developing country,” “third world,” “second world?” (what is that, anyway?), the global south? Hanna says the social-work world prefers “lesser-industrialized nations” but I balk at this naturally because it sounds like wordy academic language that might be even more insulting. Well anyway, if Indonesia academically fits into one of those categories, my own personal experience in “lesser-industrialized nations” (being mainly only Senegal and Nicaragua, but also including Mali, Guinea-Konakry, Berkina Faso, Benin, Togo, Ghana, and to some extent Navajo Nation –so admittedly, limited) makes Indonesia unique. I am constantly shocked and grateful at how comfortable I am here. Yes, I shower out of a bucket and use a Turkish toilet. Yes, I have currently had only 1 of 21 days where my stomach felt normal, and yes, I am experiencing a bit of full-belly starvation (i.e. the bloated but unsatisfied feeling of a diet of 75% rice –fried rice for breakfast is a norm here). BUT –what I find shocking and amazing –I am realizing, has mostly to do with the people I am working with –of vastly different character than my prior experience.

Why I left the development world is because it felt very much like pushing other countries to do our Western agenda. Ok, I speak mostly of Senegal. But even my work “developing” the poor and immigrant communities in Washington, D.C. The initiatives and priorities of whatever organization I was working for, while important to the people we were serving, weren’t their same priorities. Lots of frustration resulted. I was pushed instead to become an “advocate” because I think it is a much better use of everyone’s resources to ask communities we want to help what their goals are, consult with them perhaps, and then help them achieve their own goals.

That means they have to have goals. And what I found in Africa is that people’s spirit and self confidence is so low they often don’t have any beyond daily survival. That and wanting to leave to go to America, Spain, etc. I was hard pressed to find people who were inspired and motivated to make improvements in their own communities. So I developed a kind of worship for them. It may just be the crowd I am circling in, but here, those types of people abound. And I think it actually is a good representation of Indonesia’s entrepreneurial social spirit. A drive down any road turns up numerous NGOs –often doubling as people’s homes. It seems the average Indonesian, if not going after a government job or a farmer, is looking to get involved with their pet social cause, even start their own NGO. So its been really exciting. It has also left me feeling that I might be in the wrong place. They don’t need me here to push them –what I am used to, even if I don’t like it. They also don’t seem to need me to connect them to resources –what I ended up doing in Senegal and would like to do in the future. There is an intense web of “politics” here –I think most young people have been “activists” since they were young and in college –and so the NGO world is highly incestuous –everyone knows each other and has their opinions –and so lines are already drawn as to who will work with whom. Obviously, 2 months is too short for me to understand these complex relationships –and even if I was here for longer it might not really be necessary. Indonesians seem well on the way to figuring out how to solve their social problems on their own.

Well, there’s one area where no one seems to know the answers however. How to enforce rule of law. How to get the law enforcement agencies to actually enforce the law. How to get the courts to administer justice rather than favors for those who either pay them out of offer favors in return. I met with a number of activists yesterday, lawyers, “paralegals,” (Indonesia enacted a new law in 2011 that allows regular citizens to practice law if they go through certain training and then take a test. !! So “paralegal” here means someone who has gone to some trainings on the law and are legal activists in their communities.) and journalists to ask them what they think needs to happen to make the conflict in Central Sulawesi stop and for peace to be sustainable. Most agree that effective law enforcement is a major element. But people are at a loss for how to make that happen. Corruption here has, in the words of one activist, been turned from bad into good. Officials used to be embarrassed to be exposed as dealing in corruption. But since it is so widespread and now out in the open, officials are free to taut the “benefits” of corruption –i.e. “pay me and get your way” and are no longer publicly ashamed of handling their affairs this way. How can one even hope to possibly change a system this entrenched?

So, maybe there is a place for me here. However, though I have been blessed to have some excellent translators, language is a serious barrier. If I do decide to do this kind of work in the future, perhaps I need to pick one country or culture and stick with it. Learn the language really well. I don’t know if being a conflict “consultant” and working around the world will allow me the depth of understanding that is one of my main tenants for effective work.

But –finally to explain my week. So, after much back and forth deliberation with my now second supervisor, Saras, I was elated that she invited me to attend a “paralegal” training in Palu, a major city in Central Sulawesi. The actual dates of the training were unclear from the beginning –but we finally settled it that it was going to be Sunday and Monday. As Tentena, where I live, was supposedly a “6 hour” bus ride from Palu, I was going to leave on Saturday. I woke up Saturday morning, packed my bag, and happily marched over to Lian’s to get picked up. Something seemed fishy from even the night before (I think they forgot to call to save me a spot on the bus) but I suspended my doubt as I did my morning English-Indonesian class with the women’s school. As we finished up, Lian told me she had some bad news –there wasn’t a spot for me on the bus, so I would have to wait until Sunday. I was disappointed and slightly panicked –but I tried to keep the faith. If I left on Sunday I would still have all day on Monday to meet with Saras, her supervisor from higher up in the organization (who supposedly spoke lots of English!), and the other lawyers.

I showed up bright and early at Lian’s on Sunday, only to learn that no buses would be leaving until after the whole town got out of church. So we left around 11 and after a full day’s travel on windy mountain roads to a soundtrack of booming remixes of “Barbie girl” and its Indonesian equivalents, I arrived in Palu at 9pm. I woke up early the next morning ready to finally have my first day “at work.” Lita, an environmental activist and friend of Lian’s, who’s house I was staying at, gently pointed out that NGO workers “have a habit” of not starting work until 11am, “since they usually work until midnight.” (The latter I think was just an attempt to soften the blow to her countrymen’s work-ethic –I have never seen anyone but Lian work until midnight.) But I was determined. It seemed that Saras’s house doubled as the LBH (Legal Aid) office, so after a quick (once I found a functional compter) google search Lita called me a cab. I showed up at Saras’s house which to all appearances was just her house –and to my ultimate dismay seemed either utterly deserted or filled with still-sleeping NGO workers. As the taxi driver pulled away, I contemplated camping out outside her gate, but decided the better option was to find the nearest internet café and email Saras and Lian.

The nearest internet café was about a 2km walk down a highway where I received the customary calls of “bole” (foreigner) and was asked by about 5 motorcycle drivers if I needed a ride somewhere. But no one knew what wifi was except me, apparently, so I continued to walk. Lian was right on it-as soon as I emailed her she emailed right back that Saras had contacted her and the training was at a hotel, for which she gave me the address. Yes! I was so close! I got in a public “cab” –a turquoise van whose front end was so close to the ground I feared we might bottom out and waited to be delivered to my job.

Well, I got there, and walked in to a quiet room of serious assumed lawyers, and scanned the room as quickly and inconspicuously as I could being an awkward looking white person stumbled in to a room of Indonesians. Of course, I caused an instant stir, but caught no sight of Saras. My pathetic levels of Indonesian left me just asking “Saras? Saras?” –to which I was ushered to the back of the room to speak with who seemed to be in charge. Saras was not there, I managed to eke out. She was sick. She’s pregnant, a woman told me under her breath. WHAT? Well, I had already caused enough of a commotion and interrupted the meeting, and worse, no one knew why I was there as I could absolutely not communicate myself. So, I did the best thing I could think of. I sat down at the roundtable and pretended to look really serious and engaged in the presentation. I could figure that they were talking about gender stereotypes, and so I actually wanted to take notes so I could google translate them later and find out what they were about –maybe I could use them for my domestic violence training?

After about an hour we had a break for lunch. In keeping with Indonesia’s customary hospitality, everyone encouraged me with one of the only English words they proudly knew “Eat!” They didn’t even know who I was! But I kindly declined, and again ran out into the sun to find an internet café. “Lian –I have a problem.” I explained. Thank god Lian is somehow an American in an Indonesian body and is permanently on gchat. She gave me some Indonesian instructions to convey to the people in charge –she wanted to talk to them on the phone. I went back and she explained to them who I was and inquired about Saras. Then she got back on the phone with me to explain. Saras was in fact sick –and pregnant. “Why didn’t she tell us!?!” I exclaimed in dismay. Lian did not know. (I have since found out, no one wanted to tell me, but Saras is a shady character. I think she must have been one of only a couple of lawyers that Lian knew and so, months ago, when I asked her to find me a legal supervisor, this was the best she could do.) Why, especially, would she have directed me to the meeting at the hotel without even telling us that she wasn’t going to be there?

So, we did the best we could under the circumstances. Lian talked to them and explained that I was a law student and came to Indonesia to study the intersection between conflict and natural resource law. Unfortunately, the training was mostly about gender and the law. (An interesting topic –but I was in Palu to go over the curriculum I had created for the women’s school about natural resource law.) I would spend the rest of the day at the training and then consult with Lian after about what to do next. In the meantime, she would get in touch with Saras.

The training was interesting, even though I was mostly lost because it was in all Indonesian. As I explained, the new law allows ordinary Indonesians to not only educate the public on the law, but to also take actual cases to court –without going to law school. They can attend any number of “paralegal trainings” and when they are ready take a test that qualifies them to go to court. This is so interesting –I want to find out more about it. On the one hand, it’s a great way to spread legal education quickly and widely across Indonesia. This will probably have really positive effects over rule of law. People knowing that they have rights and what the laws are will be one of the first steps in getting them to demand that they are enforced. However, I can’t possibly begin to understand how you could try to practice, or even understand, law, without going to law school. Especially in a place like Indonesia. I have read and continue to read every law journal article I can find on law in Indonesia. And while I knew it was complicated before I came –it is INFINTELY more complicated than I could have imagined. Although there is a sort of hierarchy of laws –there are so many different legal systems in Indonesia that from what I understand, how you win in court is by picking what law you want to apply to your case and arguing why that is the one that should. First of all, Indonesia’s legal system is modeled off of the Dutch legal system, which I am going to have to research –which is divided between public and private law. But there is national law, from the Constitution, Parliament, the President, and then going down into provincial laws, governor’s laws, district laws, and others (I haven’t translated yet how they are different, but there are at least 3 other categories.) BUT, then there is an entirely DIFFERENT system of law –called adat law –which is arguably even law, but is basically “traditional law.” It is unclear whether this is law or custom, but, especially with regards to land rights, it is extremely important. There are basically two systems of land rights operating in Indonesia –the traditional system where agricultural land is passed down from generation to generation, and the “Western” system –title law, that was brought here with the Dutch. As the Dutch dealt with land via title –foreigners and anyone given land at the time was part of the title system. Not unexpectedly, there is no title in the traditional system. It is even more complicated because sometimes its not even individual ownership but community ownership, with unclear boundaries, people moving from place to place but still laying claim to the same fields, etc. Indonesia has made various efforts to get all land under the same system, with various disastrous effects. So from what I understand now, the courts will respect adat law, but basically its up to the lawyers to argue which of the various legal systems should apply to a given case.

But I digress. I found out all of this stuff after I returned to Lita’s house entirely discouraged from the training and not meeting Saras. Lita was hysterical and almost immediately asked me why I hadn’t asked her for help –and most importantly, why I had insisted on working with Saras. She used to be the Director of a coalition of environmental NGOs in Central Sulawesi, and so, as I am discovering on my own, is quite famous in this region. (She now has a 2 year old, and so has tried to cut down her activities, but as many activists do, she has trouble not being involved in everything all of the time.) To my benefit. She told me she knows all the lawyers and legal activists in the area and almost immediately started calling everyone under the sun to arrange meetings for me for the next day. This was a bit of a problem for me –I only thought I was going to be here for 1 day and so in addition to only having 1 professional outfit am miserably equipped in other supplies. But yesterday was amazing: I met the Vice-director at the Institute for the Development of Legal Studies and Human Rights Advocacy Central Sulawesi, who sat with us for over 2 hours discussing the conflict here. We then went to a local freelance reporter headquarters where they specialize in reporting on the conflict and were all to eager to answer my questions. Finally –and this is the best part –I met my first real lawyer –Sujar. Sujar and Saras used to both work on the Peura case (the town where I am supposed to do the training on natural resource law) a number of years ago. Peura has since dropped the case indefinitely because the town is divided on the benefits of the hydroelectric plant in the town. But the case –and the conflict –threaten to rise up again at any time, depending on the effects of the plant in the community. Just a couple of months ago, a farmer was electrocuted during a storm while working in his field that was next to one of the towers.

Supposedly there was an argument at LBH, and Saras split off and started her own branch –LBH Apik. LBH Apik is relatively new and consequently disorganized. They were the ones who held the training I attended. The lawyer from “higher up” that I met there did speak good English –her name is Beauty (?) –the only problem is she’s from Lombak. I was really excited to meet her because, as she explained, she used to be a commercial lawyer, but she was a victim of domestic violence and so now she is a human rights lawyer specializing in women and children’s rights. I asked her if she had an experience in training either women’s groups or police and she said she had both! We started talking about plans for me to go to Lombok to work with her and then her come to Tentena to do the training with us. But when I told Lian our idea, she explained that the culture and the laws in Lombok were entirely different than in Sulawesi and so it wouldn’t work. How is one country with 17,000 islands ever going to succeed at democracy or have a unified system of law!!! But anyway, Beauty said that the LBH Apik branch in Lombak is much more advanced and organized. They processed over 1,000 cases last year (although some of these were only protection orders, etc. and didn’t go to court). Although I would love to go see her work –she promised me she could take me to court with her and to meet clients –I am not sure at this point what my goals are and what is the best way to meet them.







So, Sujar works for the older, more established LBH, and is supposedly one of the best, and only “serious” human rights lawyers in this area. I think its kind of trendy to work for an NGO here, and people do it for the wrong reasons –one of which, of course, being money and one of the more stable career options here. But just in meeting Sujar, you can tell that he is serious. He agreed to come to Lita’s home last night, after a day of traveling, since Lita had to take care of her kid. He then sat down with us to talk for over 3 hours. He answered a significant amount of my list of questions about Peura and land law in Indonesia, and then sat down and drew out a chart of the hierarchy of laws in Indonesia and what types of laws fit where. It was a long session and I think by 8pm we were all tired. Today, I am going to YMP (Yayasan Merah Putih), a NGO that works on indigenous people’s rights. Then tomorrow, there is a citywide meeting with judges, lawyers, and other activists in the area who’s agenda is “The Role of Civil Society in Central Sulawesi in Combating Mafia Law,” and then on Saturday I am going to a training in the conflict zone in Palu. So, I suddenly have a full schedule, but, unfortunately, only one outfit to wear to them. I guess that’s good enough. Never a dull moment.

Ethical Dilemma -Peura


**Another blog post from online Leadership course this summer.**

So, here’s what I know about the place I am supposed to be making a curriculum for this summer –Peura. Not really sure if this blog post is going to have a point –I more just want to record some information I learned about the other day.

So, Peura. Here’s a link and a video (http://www.insideindonesia.org/weekly-articles-105-jul-sep-2011/the-power-to-rebuild-15101480; http://vimeo.com/27972452; ) if you want to read/watch about the story ) but just briefly: Peura is a town where PT Poso Energy, a national company, set up a hydroelectric plant. They didn’t follow the regulations of their permit and instead of building the plant towers along the mountain ridges, they built it right through the center of town, along with some other violations. The town is bitterly divided over what to do about it. There was some activity around a class action law suit a number of years ago (which my supposed-to-be supervisor, Saras, and my current stand-in supervisor, Sujar, worked on together before there was an internal fight in their organization and they split off), but it was dropped because the town didn’t have a unified stance. Half the town wants to sue PT Poso Energy and kick them out (though the kicking out part is kind of a threat to get them to comply –I don’t know what went into thinking this threat out). The other half is appreciative of development, industry, and their ability to find jobs now. In an area that just recently reached a tenuous end of conflict, old prejudices threaten to flare up.

A weird element of this is that Jusuf Kalla, who was formerly Vice President under current President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono (SBY –and apparently you can change VPs here) is highly involved in the Peura case on the side of PT Poso Energy (see article.) Jusuf Kalla is also rumored to be lining up to run in the next presidential elections. I mentioned that I wrote a grant that helped Lian and Mosintuwu win $100K –the Coexist Prize. Coexist is an interfaith peace organization, and after Lian won, they asked her to devolve her involvement in the Peura case because it was bad for publicity.

All of this somewhat detrimentally affects what I came here to do. When I met Lian last summer, I told her that I wanted to come work for her, but that I was going to law school, so was there anything I could do from a law perspective? She instantly jumped at the idea –at the time she was in the midst of working with the Peura people –and told me that she needed a curriculum on land and natural resource rights. I worked with her throughout the semester to get a handle on the conflict and how land and natural resource law, and access to justice, was related. But then when I got here, I found out that the Coexist Prize had requested that she tone down her activities in Peura.

This instantly put me ill-at-ease. I certainly don’t want to get Lian or anyone else killed or in trouble, nor myself. And the safety situation here is something I can’t hope to understand. I don’t think people are focused on hurting foreigners –but Lian constantly gets threats and “visitors” to her house –either watching her, or occasionally threatening to burn it down. Both Lian and Sue assured me that working on this curriculum wouldn’t cause any trouble. But I was worried. What if someone caught sight of a bulé (foreigner) trompin’ around Peura with Lian talking to people? Someone humorously reminded me that this is the ex-vice and possibly future president we are talking about –he is unlikely to feel threatened by a bulé in some ratty clothes. So I have been proceeding –albeit without knowing if this is the right ethical decision, personally or professionally (what do you guys think?)

But as a result of this unease, in combination with my personal ethic of not forcing my own agenda onto others unsolicited, I have been holding back in pushing Lian to work with me on developing the curriculum. I am not sure if this has been the right strategy. I finally talked with Sue and Hanna about it last week. Sue has been working with Lian for over 3 years, and Hanna is a bit more forward than I am, and both of them emphasized that I needed to push Lian. Her schedule is way overbooked and so if left to her own devises she will never have time for me, but if I constantly pester her she will make time. I argued that I didn’t feel comfortable with this. Even people with overbooked schedules prioritize. They do the stuff that’s most important to them first. If the Peura curriculum wasn’t making it onto the agenda, it meant it wasn’t a top priority. Perhaps even more so because of the Coexist situation. I felt especially uncomfortable pushing her to do something that might be risky for her professionally and even personally. But Sue and Hanna insisted, so I agreed that when I got back I would push her.

That I did and we met a couple of days ago. Although I am not entirely satisfied with the results (see subsequent posts), I did find out some fascinating, if not disheartening, information. I have heard over and over that Lian is “dedicated” and “owes a lot” to the people of Peura. She is a single mom who decided against her family and community’s boding to have her baby. She was subsequently ostracized, and I think Peura took her in. But in addition, back when the situation was really heated in Peura, Lian was their faithful, and only rational, leader.

She told me a story about how one night a group of male NGO workers came to her house in the middle of the night to tell her that 45 men from Peura were rallying to ride their motorcycles to the local police department and burn it down. The NGO workers solicited her help in convincing the men not to do it, which she did and succeeded. After that, the NGO workers met a few times at Lian’s house to explain the entire situation in Peura and all the problems there. They subsequently dropped the entire issue in Lian’s lap. Lian, a less than 5 foot woman on crutches, proceeded to ringlead a bunch of rowdy, and righteously angry, Peura men. She told them she wouldn’t work to help them unless they submitted entirely to her and only did what she told them, and ran all their “ideas” by her. She laughed as she told me that finally the men came to her and said “Ok, what if we don’t burn the police station down? What if we just drive by at midnight and all honk our horns?” She gave them the go ahead. In the meantime, while she was breaking her back to mitigate the situation, the NGO workers who had dropped the problem on her had left the region and were campaigning for themselves with the media and government about all the work they were doing in Peura. Not only was Lian completely abandoned to single-handedly mitigate the conflict, but she was taken advantage of and exploited for the benefit of the NGO workers as well.


I hope I am finally going to get to go to Peura and meet these people next Wednesday (please don’t let any unforeseen events –all to common here, spring up and get in the way). I will not only get to learn about the mysterious “cultural context” of Peura (each community here has a vastly different culture, laws, norms, etc.) but will also get to ask them questions (my most burning one –who has TITLE to the land in Peura), and what they want out of the curriculum. This is an element that is so cool about working at Mosintuwu. Lian doesn’t want me to create a curriculum about what I think is valuable from my reading, or even from meeting with my legal supervisor. She wants to go ask the people of Peura what they want to learn. Lets just hope I have time to get all that down into a curriculum before I leave. 

Some Real Reckoning -Where I lost my scholarship and confronted Domestic Violence in Poso


**Another blog post from my online Leadership course. **

Ok everyone –I need your help. Just in case you are speed reading, skip down to the bottom, after I have a heart to heart with perhaps myself. (I’ll put a ***where you should start reading.) So, the past few days have been (and continue to be) a struggle that I have been expecting for a while. This might be oversharing with you guys, but for some reason, I feel inspired to share –if not only because its slightly lonely being the only law student around here. Ok, I had a full-tuition scholarship that is dependent on keeping a 3.0 –which I did not. Just the other day, I got my last grade back. I was on “probation” this semester and so have not only had about 0 self-esteem (as with most of us –in my former life I prided myself on/identified myself with my academic skills), but have also been really, almost sickeningly scared, and working really really hard and having no life. So tons of thoughts are going through my head: am I just not that smart? Maybe I’m not meant to be here –maybe my brain is not meant to “think like a lawyer.” I keep trying to go over how I spent my time this semester and find ways to chide myself for wasting it. I shouldn’t have gotten a dog. I should spend less time on the phone with my mom, who underwent 3 surgeries this semester. None of these thoughts are really productive, good for me, or really going to do anything. But its really hard to stop thinking them when I am in a place that doesn’t have all the distractions that we do in America. Beer. TV. Friends. Freedom to go outdoors and go for a long walk, hike, run, bike ride. The ability to stay in bed for the whole day without people wondering if I am ok. Ice cream. Anyway, the part that I think is worth thinking about is that I was really very hesitant to come to law school. My site mate here is a social worker (sorry if I’ve told you guys this a million times) and she said yesterday what is really true –I have a social worker’s mind and heart. I just happen to be in law school. When I was contemplating applying to law school, I sought out the advice of those I love and respect. I talked to family and friends, mentors, coworkers, and even took a trip back to Gettysburg, my alma mater, to speak to my philosophy professors who I am still close with. Almost everyone not only seriously questioned why I wanted to go to law school, advised me against it in this economic climate, or downright persuaded me to change my mind. Why didn’t I get a MA in International Affairs? Why didn’t I find a job that could sustain me financially for the moment and apply to ideal jobs with the same vigor I would have to apply in law school? And of course, EVERYONE had their piece to say about the tremendous financial burden I would be taking on which really didn’t line up with the type of work I wanted to do (like what I am doing this summer). I wasn’t sure I was going to go up until the last minute, but something in me persisted. I really believe in the power of law to change people’s lives. After a number of years doing development work and becoming really disenchanted with the entire system (in my mind, its kind of neocolonialism), I came to realize that what I really wanted to do was be an advocate for people. Be invited into their communities and instead of having a prescription for what would make their lives better –to ask them what they wanted to do and then figure out how I could use my access to provide resources for them. Law school seemed, in part, like an obligation. I was born in a place and with a mind and have had a life that has led me right up to this opportunity –all I had to do was take the leap. If I had the chance to receive such a high level of education it is kind of my duty, as a thank you to the world, and as a way to make more people have the opportunities that I have –to take advantage of it. Anyway, I found out very close to acceptance time that I got the scholarship to DU. I was elated. Suddenly all the questions I had been asking myself for years seemed solved –if I could go to school with tuition paid I could still get to do what I wanted when I graduated. So here I am. But now that I lost the scholarship, I find myself back where I was a year ago. All of those questions are coming back. Why do I want to be here? Is this the right place for me? Am I willing to put my dreams at risk by taking on this financial burden? So, it has been a little bit of a depressing and traumatic couple of days. 

***But here is finally what I need your help with. Yesterday morning, we had a meeting with Lian (the Director at the Women’s school), Hanna, the social worker, Sondang, an Indonesian mental health worker from Jakarta who is volunteering here over the summer, and Ibu Lina, one of the women that graduated from the women’s school and is now a facilitator. As I mentioned before, the women’s school is diversifying its programs to meet more of the community’s needs –in part because of the grant I won for them (thank god that happened –I keep reminding myself I am good at SOMETHING). The women’s school is currently serving as a kind of ad hoc safe house for domestically abused women and children–which is a huge problem here, as you might imagine. They want to make this program more formal, and a huge part of that will be community education. We sat down yesterday to plan out how Hanna, Sondang, and I can use our time here to further the program. 

The first question that we discussed was “Men abuse their wives and children because they have the power. How can we get them to give up that power?” While the others discussed this from the mental health perspective, I was brainstorming on my own. So that is my first question to you. Men kind of always have the power –they are usually physically stronger than women (and maybe for other reasons?). And don’t get me wrong –I know that there are vast DV problems in the states too. But I am trying to articulate and understand the difference –because I know within my peers growing up DV wasn’t really an option. I thought of three things: 

1. The law. Obviously. Rule of law is strong in our country and so perhaps men don’t think about it because they know there are serious repercussions. But here, though Indonesia has seemingly good laws on the books (anyone with experience in DV law? I am looking for some good comparisons from the States –like a state with exemplary DV laws and one with bad ones. I think Professor M is trying to work on improving Colorado’s so maybe that is a good place to start.), there is ABSOLUTELY NO enforcement. Obviously, this will be where I will be working. Come back to that in a bit. 

2. Social pressure. The others insisted that this is the most powerful element in Indonesian culture. People adjust their behavior based on how they are viewed/treated by others in their community. A HUGE part of this is the church/mosque. A lot of the training the women’s school hopes to do is going to be through churches and mosques. These places already serve as “safe houses” for women and children suffering from DV, but, disturbingly, the religious leaders’ response is to pray with them. So educating perpetrators is a long way down the line –first they will train the women facilitators from the school and others they identify as “allies,” then they will educate the religious leaders and communities, and finally come up with a strategy for how to identify and reach the perpetrators. I suggested that at some point, I would really like it if they could convince the religious leaders to, once they find out that a woman or child is being domestically abused, to not allow their husband to come to services. Kind of like in Catholicism where if you “sin” you are not supposed to go up and take mass –kind of a public shaming. I feel like this would do a lot to make people think twice about DV. Maybe this is naïve. 

3. Quality of life. Another aspect of living abroad, at least in the cultures I have experienced, is, as I am sure many of you are familiar with, the vastly different and strictly enforced division of labor between men and women. Senegal was the worst. Men’s main function was farming –which was ridiculously hard work (but the women actually farmed too) but only lasted part of the year. The other part the men would mostly sit in the public areas drinking tea and playing cards while the women cooked, took care of the kids, did laundry, cleaned, etc. All of us Peace Corps volunteers were on a constant campaign to convince the men that taking a more fair share of the work, among its many benefits, would also allow them to be closer to and spend more time with their wives. We would explain how its fun and normal for couples in the U.S. to cook together –that it can be a whole event that people actually plan for and enjoy. This mostly got laughs. But my point is –I think maybe men in the U.S. give up their power because it makes their life more enjoyable. I think men actually enjoy being more a part of their family life –taking care of their kids, working side by side with their wives around the house. What do you guys think? 

So basically, I am asking you guys first to help me brainstorm about what seems like an insurmountable task that we in the U.S. have at least, in some segments of society, and in part, managed to surmount. Here it seems impossible. How to make men give up their stronghold? (And of course, this pervades to all aspects of society and is the source of much of Indonesia’s social, political, etc. ills). But I guess the more important question for us is this one: how to encourage rule of law? The group asked me to take on a task that seems impossible: they want to gather the local police and have me give them a training on Indonesia’s DV laws, people’s rights, and why the police should enforce them. For example, Indonesia’s DV law says that anyone has the right to report DV and the police have to respond –with either a report, a preliminary protective order (if requested), or a protective order. There are criminal sanctions listed for every type of DV. Yet no one ever reports, and if they do, the police do nothing. This gets back to my intro. Yesterday, while we were talking, the women explained how one time at a demonstration the women were doing against DV, the police were taunting them and shouting at them that if they orgasmed, it wasn’t rape. This is also the experience of individual women if they report DV to the police –they are belittled and made fun of. Hanna said this happens in the states as well –but it seems to me that that has to be isolated cases. Does anyone have any experience in this area? They all kind of laughed at me that I was so appalled. But I explained myself –it is not naiveté (ok, maybe it is a bit), but I am 29 years old and I have seen a lot of messed up stuff in the world. However, for some reason, my heart remains young and I never cease to be deeply effected and shocked by how bad people can be to each other. And I felt in that moment why I am in law school. And why I need to stay, even if I have to pay. I will figure something out. But ever since I was a little kid, injustice effects me, it hits me right in the heart, and shocks me every time. As a kid, when I felt something was unjust I would scream and throw a fit and go upstairs and throw things around my room. I was pretty terrified by my own rage. But now I have figured out another way to deal with injustice –to use my life to work hard and make at least a tiny impact in tipping the scales of justice just a little more towards the good. I really think I am joining a revolution –lol –and you guys should get on board. (I am sure there are lots of other people who think this as well and have already started –like Lawyers without Borders). Law is the way. It is our social compact with each other to treat each other with decency and fairness. Nowhere is this more obvious than in a country with no rule of law where people are getting hurt all the time –especially in a community like this where lack of rule of law means people resort to violence to avenge their injustices. It should be just as obvious why I want to go to law school to save the world as it would be if I got a degree in development. Really, it should be more so. The women’s story is also why educating the police on why they should enforce DV laws seems like such an impossible task. As I see it, the biggest problem is perhaps that the police are rotated in from outside the community. I was thinking of starting by asking them don’t they want to protect their mothers, sisters, wives, and daughters against this kind of act? I want to ask them to imagine if it was someone they loved that were sitting in front of them –how could they do something like that? But the reality is probably that these people are government cronies shipped in from the capital or somewhere else where they have a vastly different lifestyle. Also, a problem I have noticed in poor countries is that once many people get into power, the get nauseatingly arrogant, lazy, condescending, and comfortable in their airconditioning, nice consistent paycheck, and powerful connections. Power corrupts, right? But to deal with this depressing reality –I have kind of come to think that this is a result of the culture of poverty. (The culture of poverty is actually a thing that I am really interested in studying in depth at some point.) They grew up poor, witnessing things many of us can’t even imagine, and so once they get to a safe place, a place where they can provide for their family, and where people respect them (counteracting a life of self-depreciation for being poor and second-class in the world), they go a specific kind of crazy. So…that’s the big question. Should I accept this challenge? If so, what should I do? Do you guys have any thoughts/experience? Any resources I could start consulting? Well, at least I am no longer sick and feeling underworked. Its going to be a crazy rest of the summer. 

Poor People's Summit! Thats my goal. A UN of poor people, reps from each community in each country (starting with Mosintuwu)

**Another post from my online Leadership course. During a session on Strategic Thinking and Values Based Leadership we were asked to create an organization that would use both of these.**





By now, you have all heard my ranting about development. I actually revisited the idea for my organization today while I was meeting with workers from an NGO that focuses on indigenous people’s rights. After I asked them all my questions and about their respective jobs, they wanted to know more about what I was studying and why I was in Indonesia. I told them I was focusing on conflict resolution and international law, and someone asked me if I was going to focus my career on the conflict in Poso. I answered that I didn’t know –that was part of why I was here this summer –to see if there was a need for my skills. I asked them openly what did they think: was there a place for an American lawyer in their community? They answered very frankly: no. I kind of expected that was the answer. Each day, I find out more that I am here to learn for my own benefit but that, not being fluent in Indonesian, not really understanding their multiplicity of cultures, or the complexity of their legal system –there is very little I can offer. And even if I spent the years it would require to learn all of that –I don’t think I would be adding much value for the work it would cost. Indonesians are well on their way to solving their own social problems.

I don’t think I am adding nothing while I am here. But what I have continued to realize in my experience is the biggest value that I bring is just that –my experience. When it comes down to it, being an American doesn’t mean I know anything more about the world or how to live life than others. But it does mean that I may have had access to a lot of experiences, or at least different ones. The biggest “teaching moment” I have perhaps had so far here came quite unexpectedly. As you may know, Indonesia has one of the world’s largest deforestation problems. Natural resource rights are a HUGE issue here –not only because the government is tromping all over the rights of indigenous peoples, but because Indonesia is so rich in natural resources, if it manages them right it can really prosper but if it manages them wrong it will have huge national consequences as well as consequences for the global climate. As I may have mentioned, one of the projects of Institute Mosintuwu (besides the women’s school) is Project Malinuwu –an environmental education program. I accompanied them to speak at a church and at a couple of schools, and was impromptu asked to speak about my experience with climate change. I realized on the spot that I had quite a stark example: the village I served in in Senegal had experienced almost complete deforestation in the lifetime of my host father (he was 89 when I was there). Since I told that story at the school, Lian and Lita have asked me to repeat it over and over. Today, as I explained what I had learned about climate change while I was in Senegal, I could see the wheels turning in the minds of everyone I was speaking to. The person in charge of the REDD Monitoring Coalition (Indonesia is the first country to implement a REDD –carbon reduction/exchange –program) expressed the most interest and said he wanted to research why climate change had occurred in Senegal.

It has long been an idea of mine that this is exactly the type of exchange that needs to happen in the “developing world” not only from Americans or Westerners to people in developing countries –but horizontally as well. I first thought of this idea when I traveled to Mali during my service in Senegal. I had been working for over a year trying to encourage the women in my village to start a community garden, and trying to start a garden at the elementary school. I later learned that the real problem was village politics –but for that whole time I dealt with varying reasons why the garden wasn’t taking off –the biggest being there wasn’t enough water. But when I traveled to Mali –a mostly natural desert –I was blown away by the oases of green gardens shimmering everywhere against the red sand. Mali had a lot less “water development” (i.e. proper wells, and even water spigots) than Senegal did. I was amazed to find that more than once a day, women would travel several miles back and fourth with gourds of water on their heads (Senegalese had already converted to plastic basins). Mali is a lot less developed than Senegal. It is further inland and so perhaps less developed because it doesn’t benefit from Senegal’s access to a large coastline. But I think this brings some benefits to Malian people as well. I felt that Malians were still proud to be Malian and to be African. Senegalese however, suffer from a national discouragement about their status in the world. In my experience, Senegalese were constantly putting themselves down –either personally, culturally, naturally, or as Africans. They have truly accepted what the world thinks of their global ranking. “Development” makes them feel like just that –people that need to develop. Western culture is swallowing them whole –through TV, interaction with tourists who come to enjoy their coasts, and the influx of aid workers and other expats come to “help” them. As such, people are entirely discouraged from trying anything on their own to do small things to improve their condition –like gardening. Why would they want to spend their energy on a garden –even if it would bring them improved nutrition and health –and perhaps a small income –when people in developed countries were dealing in fancy cars and beautiful lavish houses? Fresh vegetables seemed like a laughable pittance.

Malian’s have not yet been affected to the same degree as Senegalese. They are still willing to spend all day walking back and forth with gourds of water so they can have nutritious food to eat. I left Mali wanting to do everything in my power to raise money to bring a few Senegalese from my village to Mali to see what was possible for them to achieve in their own environment –to give them an attainable aspiration and infuse them with hope and pride in being Africans.

It didn’t happen while I was in Senegal but I still entertain the dream –and it is fed by experiences like the one I had today. There is so much power in the “developing” world –and I feel it would be better unleashed if people from those countries could interact with each other and learn from each others experiences than if their only exposure to the rest of the world is with Western countries. So the organization I would set up, with a lot of grant writing, of course, would be a sort of study-abroad program for people in developing countries to visit other developing countries. Senegalese villagers could visit Malian community gardens. Indonesians could go to Senegal to witness what deforestation and climate change could do to a country. Conflict survivors and peace activists from here could go to other countries recovering from conflict and exchange ideas. Women fighting for equality could visit other women’s groups around the world and do the same. Same goes for small scale local economic projects. Last week, when I was talking to the women at the women’s school about women’s rights, one of the topics was equal pay. I told them we still don’t have equal pay in America and told them about my experience at my last job (I was seriously underpaid) –where all of my guy friends encouraged me to ask for a raise but most of my girl friends just offered empathy at my situation. I said I think part of the problem is guys are more aggressive about their value and in asking for a raise but girls are uncomfortable with that. They were very interested. Next week I hope to share with them an article I just read in the Economist about how one of the problems with American politics right now is women’s reluctance to get involved and run for positions. It referenced how Hilary Clinton, Sarah Palin, and Nancy Pelosi were brutalized by the media, oftentimes for their looks, and how this perhaps was very damaging in discouraging women from taking the risk of getting involved in politics if that was how they were going to be judged.

I think that the sharing of like experiences and ideas helps instigate creative involvement better than telling people what to do does. I was lecturing them about women’s rights but the true “teaching moment” was when I just talked honestly about my own experience and the problems women were facing in America. This really got their wheels turning. Later, when we were practicing making sentences with our new vocabulary, half of their sentences were about women getting equal pay. Something about relating to them in a common struggle had reached them more than lecturing them from on high about some abstract values. I could only hope that they might attempt to negotiate a better salary for themselves in an attempt to solve the problem I faced in their own lives. “Development” creates a hierarchy in itself that propagates low self-esteem and stifles creativity and hope. So my future organization would provide the resources for people in developing countries to travel to other developing countries facing a similar situation, get to know people there. The agenda would stop there. It would then be up to the people to come up with their own ideas to bring back to their communities. Perhaps my organization would also help them to find funding for implementing their ideas. But perhaps I would keep our mission “clear and concise” and stop there.

The vision of this organization is a peaceful world where people have options other than violence to get their voices heard and their problems addressed. Even if a world without war and violence is impossible, we can do a much better job than we are doing. In my early life, I thought the inclination towards violence was directly related to poverty. But as I continue to learn, I think it is more precisely related to lack of options. Rule of law plays a major part as well: if the justice system and law enforcement are not serving people’s needs –they need to resort to violence and get their own justice. If people lack educational or economic opportunities, or ways to get their energy out, and especially if they want to act out against the people they think are keeping them from these opportunities: violence. Of course there will always be despotic leaders who just have power, wealth, or other selfish motivations in mind and will continue to propagate violence even if they have all the opportunities in the world. But as we know, leaders need followers. I believe that the average person would not sign up to follow these types of leaders if they had other options in their lives. So the mission of this organization would be to enable people around the world to collaborate to create these types of opportunities by sharing their experiences and ideas and inspiring each other.

*
Professor V's response:
Your vision reminds me of William Loris from our readings who helped found the International Development Law Organization.  While working with Africans, he realized they should be making decisions themselves; African lawyers needed to be involved; or lawyers in whatever country they were working.  This is so important to finding common ground and creating a shared vision.

*
My response:
Yes that was definitely implicated in my idea. I was so happy to read about Loris -I love when non-traditional legal work gets a shout out in our materials! I am definitely going to come back to vision based leadership. I am beginning to think I actually do have a lot of skills and ideas about leadership -I have just never thought about them in that way before. I am entirely convinced in this methodology of empowering people to create on their own -it is the only sustainable way. Fostering the creative spirit is what drives progress, development. Look at what all the articles are about in America these days: how to foster the creative spirit and get America's economy running at full speed again -coming up with something new to hold our place on the cutting edge of innovation. But that spirit is really elusive, and hard to encourage broadly -i.e. -in "followers." Followers so easily fall into line behind their leader -but I think one of the main tenants behind values based leadership is being kind of a silent/invisible leader and instilling your followers with the ability to fill out their own potential. Then instead of having 1 creator and 20 people implementing, you have 21 creators implementing. This is what needs to happen in Africa in my opinion. Its always behind because Africans too easily line up behind Westerners because they think -and in a sense we have convinced them -that we know more. But if we step out of the spotlight, and help them get themselves into it, it would activate the creative spirit of a whole continent, and great things would happen. I believe, at least.

Law School Culture Series I: Identify Communication Skills Exhibited by Justice Sotomayor

**This is a post I made on our class blog for a online Leadership course I took this summer. We were commenting on a discussion held at DU between Justice Sotomayor and local Denver high school students.**

I started listening to the video thinking that Justice Sotomayor was going to talk about communication –and so a couple of minutes in had to come back to the question and find out what we were supposed to be doing. What’s funny is that from the very beginning of the video, I was remarking to myself what an excellent forum for good communication it was, and how good Justice Sotomayor was at communicating.

At first, as I usually do (and perhaps everyone does?) I found myself looking at her in the beginning to get an assessment of “who she was” –especially after Dean K missaid her name. She was smiling the whole time –so I thought, she’s cool. Not stuck up. Not full of herself.

Then, I was confused about why Dean K was being so meticulous about the format for answering questions –until I realized –it wasn’t a lecture! I have to say, for the first time in law school, I have begun to be that kid that sits in the back of the class slouched in my seat and looking pissed off. Professor V –please give me the “academic freedom” to speak my mind about this –as Justice Sotomayor said, I hope you can realize that I am coming from a good place and not just being pissy. Because the Orientation we had for this externship was kind of the straw that broke the camel’s back as far as lectures go for me.

I think most of my incoming class agreed that our 1L Orientation was a bit of a disaster. I appreciate that the administration is trying to break the stereotype “Look to your left. Look to your right. One of you is not going to be here when you graduate,” but I think they fell short of the mark, and perhaps in a worse way, by the alternative they proposed: “Look to your left. Look to your right. These people are going to be your colleagues for the rest of your life.” Sometime around then we also got a lecture where the main takeaway was to be nice to each other, because we might be relying on each other for jobs in the future. Another told us that every single thing we did, starting from that moment, was going to go into the registry of our peers and might come up later to haunt us. We then broke into small groups, and I was relieved to have a young woman lawyer as our facilitator –thought I might be able to better identify with her. That was until she told a story about how one of her former co-students had come in to interview with someone at her firm, and she told the interviewer that he had shown up a couple of times hung over to class. Now, I am not going to taut the merits of showing up to class hung over (I honestly don’t think I ever did this year –though I’m not saying that I wouldn’t. Its only human-life, and law school, are rough.) but these lectures back to back with each other kind of set up an early environment of paranoia amongst our class. On the last day of orientation, I was hanging out with a group of new friends I had made, and one of them said “I hope we can still hang out after orientation, because I like you guys, and I still want to be friends with you.” She was quite embarrassed and meant this in all seriousness-we were all nervous we might be hanging out with each other for the wrong reasons.

Though I get and appreciate their intentions, I feel like the orientation speakers set up our law school experience to be like a giant networking event –where we should just be nice to each other because we might need each other for a job later. I mean, come on, speaking to a group of adults and reminding us to be nice to each other –as a topic to a lecture? It made me, and a lot of us, kind of terrified. What were we getting ourselves into if people from the other side were reminding us that we had to be nice? I mean, isn’t that just something you learn as part of being a decent human being? What was law school going to do to us?

But now on to the relevant part: I think a huge part of the problem was the lecture format itself. I noticed this soon after orientation as I met with countless 2Ls and 3Ls, peer and professional mentors, lawyers at networking events and lectures. In fact, more experienced people in the legal field somewhat seemed to be throwing themselves at me to offer me their advice as I embarked on my journey. Which seemed nice enough –except when I actually listened to the advice most of them were giving me. It was some variation on the “Are you freaking out yet? Don’t worry –don’t freak out. You will be fine. Law school is going to kill you, make you hate yourself, make you feel like a worse person, as is being a lawyer, but (for some obscure unknown reason) you will be ok.” I wasn’t freaking out just yet in my first few months of law school –but in the minutes after I spoke to anyone with any experience, I started to freak out a little bit or at least feel like I should be.

This is what’s wrong with lectures. Its people coming at you with their experience and not necessarily meeting you where you are. This aspect of law school and legal culture has made me really sad. I can’t help but wonder if people were so ready with their advice because they had struggled so much but were kind of alone in it. The competitive aspect of law culture, though I think it is relatively tame here, makes us kind of isolated from our peers. Lets be honest –during law school we kind of only think about law school. It was sort of the same in undergrad –yet I never remember feeling hesitant to discuss problems I was having academically, or especially being disappointed with a grade. Here, I feel like I have to go through these struggles on my own because its kind of taboo to talk about it to my peers. We all have to be in mystery with how each other are doing. I lost my scholarship and it’s all I can think about these days (see my blog) but I don’t know if its even appropriate for me to talk about it with you guys. And the other scholars aren’t even able to tell me anyone else who has lost it that I could talk to because its that secretive among the community! So for me, it tends to feel like for people who lecture us or offer us advice, it is more of a self-confessional for them than it is a carefully considered way to reach us and help us. A moment in the spotlight, where they are not alone, and they can make their struggles into something worthwhile by advising us from the other side. The sad thing, I think, it that many of them fail at inspiring us and just terrify us or alienate us. And so to me that means –they didn’t really solve their problems –they are still going on and I am scared of them.

But if you’re going to lecture, there are some skills that can make your audience receptive to your message. Instead of really taking to heart what the Judge who lectured us during Orientation for this externship said, I really thought about why I was feeling so angry. First, he didn’t do anything to meet us where we were. We had just finished our exams the day before. Many of us had just ended perhaps the most difficult year of our lives. We would be inhuman if we hadn’t celebrated with our friends that night. If he really wanted to get us on board, he would have acknowledged the fact that we were still there that morning, ready and willing to listen to him. Instead, he started off by singling out some of the men in the audience and making them take off their hats. I can’t think of something that could alienate the audience more –not only did it embarrass them and make the rest of us identify with them in sympathy, but it made some members of the audience undoubtedly uncomfortable for the entire lecture. Let’s be honest –some people put on a hat when they didn’t have time to shower or do their hair in the morning. And once the hat’s on, even if they did shower, their hair is kind of messed up. We were meeting for an orientation –not for an interview with a downtown firm. Any events at the law school that have a dress code tell us so –if not it is appropriate to dress like a student.

Second of all, his introduction exemplified the theme of his lecture: talking down on us. Telling us that we were kids and we better shape up if we expected to do well this summer. I, as a somewhat older student, was deeply offended. Before I came to law school I had a job for 6 years. I know how to be a responsible adult and so at the very least, his lecture was wasting my time. I thought perhaps he had in mind that his audience was filled with young people that had gone right from college to law school. But then I started thinking of my peers who I knew and who were straight out of college. In a way, their closeness to academia made them more serious students than I was. I can really only think of a few students who might have not been ridiculously serious about their studies and their summer jobs. I mean, think about your audience. We’re law students –and by that I don’t mean to suggest the type of arrogance he suggested we all have. I mean to suggest the “type A” personalities we all hear about all the time. Law students are an incredibly motivated and hard working group of people. And I have never been a fan of addressing a whole group of people to correct a problem only a few people have. The people who are not serious about law school or their summer jobs wont be serious whether they get a lecture about it or not. There will always be people like that. But the rest of us, the majority, were waiting for him to speak to us, and instead he alienated us all.

Even if he was hell bent on reaching those students in the audience that wouldn’t be serious about their summer jobs, it was an absolutely ineffective method to connect with them and make them receptive to his message. I was so offended by him I thought of texting others in the audience so that I could stop frowning. But I thought maybe I was being too critical. After the lecture was over, however, I found that the students I talked to had felt exactly the same way. Here was someone standing in front of us, perhaps talking about his personal struggles in the legal profession, but mostly telling us how right he was and how wrong we were. This is the quintessential format for NOT getting people to listen to you.

That’s why I was so pleasantly surprised at the format of the video with Justice Sotomayor. Some communication genius must have thought of the idea that to reach a bunch of young kids and to inspire them to follow the lead of the Justice the best format was probably not to have her go up and lecture at them –literally talk down at them, and spout off some abstract principles for what it would take to succeed. She just got up there, smiling, put her arm on the podium, looking really relaxed and comfortable and at home, and let them ask her questions. But first, she thanked them wholeheartedly and told a story to show how she was extremely grateful to be there with them. This was just one example of a number of times where she was subtly infusing them with value. If I was in the audience, I would have asked myself why would someone so high up be so visibly touched to come and speak with me?

This is perhaps the best aspect of her expertise at communication –her demonstrating the student’s value (an extremely hard task with young people) didn’t seem trite or not genuine –and it wasn’t, because it was subtle, not contrived, and a demonstration of her real feelings. And so with little tactics like that she was accomplishing exactly what the purpose of the event was –in a very creative way. Another way she did this was by really listening and being attentive to student’s questions. I was talking to someone once who was complaining about the way another person frequently gave her advice. This was alarming to me because I felt that I was always giving advice to her too! But she explained the difference –somehow (she said, by the way you’re looking at me right now!) she could tell from my facial expression and body language that I was really listening to her before I gave her advice. She didn’t get the same feeling from the other person and felt that that person was just giving her sort of manufactured “one size fits all” advice. I think you can really see this demonstrated in Justice Sotomayor’s style. I used myexample because I don’t know what about a person’s facial expression or body language signifies that they are really listening –but I think we know it when we see it. She also took a notable amount of time to think after each question and thoroughly and thoughtfully answer each of them. She didn’t falter in this even at the end –each student’s question was treated with the same seriousness as the others.

Her style was different, though no less honest (perhaps more honest) than it would have been if she was speaking to, say, a room of politicians. She had read and responded to her audience. She was talking like a young person, and using words and experiences that the audience might be able to identify with (lots of stories about when she was young.) She was speaking to herself –she had channeled how she felt when she was a member of the audience. She used a good mix of complicated, serious discussion and more light hearted moments to get the students on board and engage them. When a student asked her what motivated her to come as far as she had, she he didn’t use some lofty explanation of her motives –which I’m sure she could if she was in a different audience. She said she’s the most stubborn person they would ever meet and used stories from her childhood that they could relate to.

Lastly, she infused an emotional and personal element into some of her answers –though not too much, and not too little. This allows her audience to emotionally identify with her and perhaps is the most effective way of making an impact. One meaningful moment was when she asked the students “Will you ever feel a part of them if you’re that different?” She went on to tell how she had struggled with this her whole life and was still struggling –but that her experience on the Supreme Court was helping her become at peace with being different. “Its ok,” she said powerfully, and then paused to let that message really sink in. Of note is that she didn’t try to make this some overzealous quote about being different. She just told them what we all want to hear at various points in our life –its ok.

Perhaps Justice Sotomayor’s communication skills are so good because they come from her worldview, which is so focused on communicating well with others. She says the law is clear but human behavior is not. So she makes sure to ask herself if she clearly understands each side before she begins. Her advice on how to deal with people: if you’re passionate about your own views, but sensitive to the other person’s views, you can improve your relationship with them. At the SC, she assumes that everyone on the court is coming from a good place. She wants her legacy to be that she understands people, and respects law. Her view is rule of law is at the foundation of our society.

I really enjoyed Justice Sotomayor’s discussion –enough that I took notes from it (and wrote a ridiculously long post.) Hearing about her worldview in the context of short stories about her personal life, her struggles, and other very humanizing subjects made it hit home and have a greater effect on me than perhaps any other motivational lecture I’ve heard so far in law school. (CO Justice Rice was also really good, for the record, for a lot of the same reasons as Justice Sotomayor.)

The Aurora shootings and my genius professor

Where do you fall on the spectrum? Protecting gun rights or protecting gun control?

At the end of the 1990's, public support for protecting gun control was the majority. But since then, especially in the last 3 or 4 years, public opinion has switched more in favor of protecting gun rights. (from PBS link below)

My heart says gun control, and the cases I read about in ConLaw 1 that eroded gun control in favor of gun rights made me angry. On my list of priorities, LIFE comes first. I don't know I hypothesize that even the most oppressed people would say what causes them the most pain is still not their oppression but the loss of their loved ones. And the majority that aren't suicidal, if they were faced with death would rage against it and towards their life of oppression.

I asked my professor why, as a top constitutional scholar in our country, he chose to focus on 2nd amendment rights. To my embarrassment, he interpreted this question as why he chose to focus on it in our class. It was embarrassing not only that he thought I was critiquing his teaching decisions, which may have lined me up with the uber-liberals (and recent college graduates) in our class which felt that any mention of our professor's beliefs was an assault against the impartiality of the class, but also because he posted my question, and his response, on Blackboard.

Ugh. So I never got the answer to why, of all the urgent causes going on in our country and our world, he has chosen to focus on 2nd amendment rights. Maybe because its a space wide open for scholarship? (He wrote the first book, forthcoming, on it). To which I would reply, for good reason. Leave it open until we sort out the more pressing problems.

The typical response to gun rights assisting "gun control" is that criminals will get their guns anyway. But if more lawful citizens have guns, they will be able to protect the rest of us when these criminals wreak havoc on our society. I will be the first to admit I am not the most well-informed citizen, but I can't recall a news story where a vigilante justice of the peace wielded his gun against a criminal and saved lives. Please, if I am wrong, site it.

But in this case, we have an ordinary citizen who bought a gun legally and used it wrongly. Below are some discussions on the subject. You may find it odd that I chose to pursue the argument of my professor. But I find, often, the best way to find the answers to your questions is to consult the opposite. And, I am extremely proud to be exposed to such a bright mind and dedicated scholar. Professor K won the hearts and minds myself and of many of my classmates, from various spots on the political and ideological spectrum. One of the most touching moments, and one I only wish could be repeated across our country, happened after Professor K and a liberal CU professor faced off on a panel about Obamacare. Professor K's arguments were rational, based on careful consideration of texts and precedents, and the impacts of the legislation. The other professor's argument was sensationalist and accusatory. He attacked Professor K personally instead of his argument.

Many of us lined up at the start of the next class to congratulate Professor K and thank him for speaking. I thought it was a really great moment -mostly liberal students going up and thanking the professor for being so professional, and so well spoken. It didn't matter about the argument. If I learned anything from Professor Kopel, it was a different approach to the same conclusion I came to in Philosophy: we know nothing. All of our arguments are based on assumptions. The other side is never "wrong." They're just coming from a different place. What we're here to do is hash out any misunderstandings that have developed along the way. This is how any debate should be carried out in our country. We are all on a quest for truth. If we're too attached to ourselves and our own truths we will never advance.


Good summary article by Prof K:
http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/312322/colorado-consensus-gun-laws-dave-kopel

Professor K appearing on PBS
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/social_issues/july-dec12/colorado_07-23.html

Professor K on Piers Morgan
http://www.mediaite.com/tv/piers-morgan-clashes-with-guest-over-whether-it-is-appropriate-time-to-discuss-gun-control/

The Volokh Conspiracy
One of the most widely read legal blogs in the United States, generally from a libertarian or conservative perspective. (from Wikipedia.) Professor K writes for this blog, and told us the Supreme Court justices consult it as well.
http://www.volokh.com/2012/08/08/large-capacity-magazines/

Articles from Professor K's CV:
http://davekopel.org/


Latest short articles

Should Congress revise our nation's gun laws? No. State gun laws do the job. Denver Post. July 29, 2012.
Colorado Consensus on Gun Laws. Broadly supported post-Columbine reforms balance gun rights and gun control. National Review Online. July 26, 2012.
Don't turn Aurora killer into celebrity. USA Today. July 19, 2012. Excerpt read by Neil Conan on National Public Radio, July 23, 2012. Analysis in Come non parlare di una strage, Il Post (Italy). July 22, 2012.
$2 Billion They'll Never See Again. Canada repeals long gun registration. America's 1st Freedom. July 2012.
OSHA Targets Shooting Range. Volokh.com. June 23, 2012.


Latest Television, Radio, Podcasts, Print Media
Colorado Inside Out. Romney and Obama battle for Colorado. Mental health of Aurora murderer. Aug. 10, 2012. Postgame: Univ. of Colo. lobbyists have other clients.
What could have stopped temple shooting? USA Today. Aug. 7, 2012. Video discussion.
How the Media, Entertainment Industry Affects Violence. iVoices.org. Aug. 1, 2012. 39 minutes.
Colorado Inside Out. Aurora murders,  forest service wildfire report. July 27, 2012. Postgame: Community reaction to the murders.
Will James Holmes get the Death Penalty? Colorado Theater Shooter Faces Death, Says Attorney. China National Central TV (CCTV), re-aired by Jewish News One. July 27, 2012.
Colorado Inside-Out. Patricia Calhoun, Mike Littwin, April Washington, and Kopel discuss the Aurora murders. July 20, 2012. 27 mins.Postgame: more on the murders.



In the Media

3-D Printer Used To Construct Gun Parts. CBS4 Denver. By Peter V. Milo. Aug. 2, 2012.
Regarding Aurora murders. Diana DeGette and Ed Perlmutter, Democratic U.S. Reps., Lead The Way Toward Tighter Gun Control After Aurora Shooting. The Colorado Independent. By Scot Kersgaard. Aug. 7, 2012. Law Professor David Kopel Argues Colorado Gun Laws Have Saved Lives/a>. Guns.com. By S.H. Blannelberry. Aug. 2, 2012. Kopel and Eugene Volokh quoted in New York Times, on Colorado gun laws. July 20, 2012. Size of ammunition cache not unusual, say gun experts. By Joey Bunch. Denver Post. July 22, 2012. Public health leaders ‘afraid to say guns’. By Katie Kerwin McCrimmon and Diane Carman. Health Policy Solutions. July 24, 2012. Tuerie d'Aurora: armes à feu à profusion. By Nicolas Bérubé. La Presse (Montreal). July 23, 2012. Denver sörjer offren efter skjutningen. Swedish National Radio. July 22, 2012. USA's vapenlagar ohotade trots Denver-skytten. Swedish National Radio. July 22, 2012. Colorado, bastano un modulo online e 152,50 dollari per un porto d'armi. America 24. July 21, 2012. Schietpartij beïnvloedt campagne VS niet sterk. Obama en Romney vermijden discussie over wapengebruik. De Staandard. July 23, 2012. En tragisk påminnelse om at vi har et nasjonalt problem. Aftenpost (Norway). July 21, 2012. Amerikas Kreuz mit dem Waffenrecht. Der Spiegel (Germany). July 21, 2012. Schweigen zum Waffenrecht. Der Taggespiegel. July 21, 2012. Právo mít zbraň nedává smysl, píší americká média po masakru na Batmanovi. IHNED (Czech Republic). July 22, 2012. Futile remedies for mass shootings.. Lots of ideas, but none would work. By Steve Chapman. Chicago Tribune. July 25, 2012.
A Land Without Guns: How Japan Has Virtually Eliminated Shooting Deaths. By Max Fisher. The Atlantic. July 23, 2012. Discusses Kopel'sarticle on Japanese gun control. (Spanish text of the article available here.) The article is an excerpt from a chapter in Kopel's book The Samurai, the Mountie, and the Cowboy: Should America Adopt the Gun Con  trols of Other Democracies? The book was named Book of the Year by the American Society of Criminology, Division of International Criminology.



Latest Monographs & Journal articles
The American Revolution against British Gun Control. Administrative and Regulatory Law News (American Bar Association). Vol. 37, no. 4, Summer 2012.
Weapons Laws of the Russian Federation. Independence Institute Issue Paper number 7-2012. May 2012. By Margot van Loon. Full translation of the statutes into English.
Mexico's Federal Law of Firearms and Explosives. 13 Engage 43 (no. 1, Mar. 2012).
Colombia's National Law of Firearms and Explosives. Full translation of the Colombian statutes, along with historical and narrative explanation. Independence Institute Issue Paper no. 3-2011. By Jonathan Edward Shaw.
Bad News for Professor Koppelman: The Incidental Unconstitutionality of the Individual Mandate. 121 Yale Law Journal Online 267 (2011). With Gary Lawson. HTML. PDF.
How Many Global Deaths from Arms? Reasons to Question the 740,000 Factoid being used to Promote the Arms Trade Treaty. 5 NYU Journal of Law & Liberty 672 (2010). With Paul Gallant & Joanne D. Eisen.

Some Articles About Women/Islam

I thought I was going to write a blog about this, but in the aim of doing well in school this semester, and because, lets face it, my thoughts are not the most important, I think you guys should just read them and then we can discuss.

"Why Do They Hate Us? The real war on women is in the Middle East"
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2012/04/23/why_do_they_hate_us?page=full

"Dear Mona Eltahawy, You Do Not Represent 'Us'"
http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/render/live/en/sites/almonitor/contents/articles/opinion/2012/al-monitor/dear-mona-eltahawy-you-do-not-re.html

"The Uprisings Will be Gendered"
http://www.jadaliyya.com/pages/index/4506/the-uprisings-will-be-gendered

"Do Arab men hate women? It's not that simple."
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/apr/25/arab-men-women-mona-eltahawy

"The Freedom of the Hijab"
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/14/opinion/the-freedom-of-the-hijab.html?_r=4