ISSUE
: “WHY I want to be a lawyer?!?!”
RULE: The purpose of this blog is to encourage discussion. I am totally aware that my opinions usually vacillate between the cynical and the idealistic, and this is my attempt, before I take the bar, to “come clean.” Thus I subject myself to you for debate. Don’t hold back.

HOLDINGS:

Sunday, August 19, 2012

Training local women to provide access to justice: a way to protect environmental rights, build peace, and limit the reach of Islamic fundamentalist groups. A Study on Poso, Central Sulawesi, Indonesia

























**At long last, my final paper that got me on to the Denver Journal of International Law and Policy. I sincerely hope this doesn't count as "publication." But I took the risk so all y'all can finally understand a bit about why I did what I did this summer.**

Introduction

            While September 11, 2001 is a day mourned as a tragedy for not only the U.S. but much of the world, on a relatively tiny island thousands of miles away, it marked the beginning of peace.[1] In the Poso region of Central Sulawesi, Indonesia, a four-year violent conflict was brought to an end.[2] Environmental rights were a primary factor of the conflict, however, division along religious lines was exacerbated by outside influences and became the “face” of it.[3]
            Today, though the situation has changed, perhaps the issue most likely to lead to future conflict continues to be environmental rights.[4] Currently, many Indonesian citizens have little access to legal redress for issues related to these rights.[5] Analysts of Islamic fundamentalist infiltration consistently recommend that an accountable, credible legal system and better access to justice remain absolutely essential to preventing the kind of vigilantism that radical groups can manipulate.[6]
            This article will advocate for an increased focus on access to justice and capacity building, particularly for women, in areas vulnerable to violent conflict. Part I will provide background on Poso’s history. Part II will describe the fundamentals of Indonesian land and natural resource rights. Part III will explain briefly Indonesia’s formal and traditional legal systems and access to justice on both levels. Part IV will make recommendations.

1)    Poso history
a)     Religious relationships
            Located between Muslim-majority South Sulawesi and Christian-majority North Sulawesi, Central Sulawesi seems like a logical place for religious conflict.[7] Yet, indigenous people had lived in harmony for generations prior to colonization.[8] However, it was under President Suharto’s regime, beginning in the 1960s, that tensions really started to rise.[9] Under Suharto, Islam was favored as the national religion.[10] By the 1980s and early 1990s, there were increasing religious rivalries for government favor and competition for jobs.[11]
            In Central Sulawesi, many Christian groups lost some of their indigenous political control.[12] Local authority was removed from customary councils of elders and transferred to a national bureaucracy.[13] Muslims were installed in high-ranking military posts, and Christians found it increasingly difficult to get their local leaders elected.[14] Young Christian students began to feel that they did not have equal access to government jobs and other economic opportunities, even if they were equally well educated and qualified.[15]
b)    Transmigration & lack of legal redress
            Suharto’s initiatives included a government-supported transmigration program to move people from the overcrowded central islands to the less populated regions.[16] Central Sulawesi was chosen as one of ten sites for migration from crowded cities.[17] New roads and highways attracted many Muslim traders to the Christian-majority highlands to cash-crop cacao and to open stores to serve the newly-wealthy cash-croppers.[18] Highland Christians also moved to the lowland Muslim-majority cities seeking higher education and jobs.[19] As the government continued to fail in providing equal access to economic opportunities, community groups became more entrenched in local, religiously based alliances to solve their daily problems.[20] Suharto used the military to preserve stability for most citizens and foreign investors.[21] Meanwhile, citizens did not have local means to negotiate and solve underlying problems, and access to national justice systems was very limited, so violence became an effective solution to social problems. [22]
c)     1998-2002
            The Asian financial crisis in 1997 ripened the scene for violence.[23]  It worsened living conditions for most citizens and created desperation for political change.[24] Citizen protests and military responses became increasingly violent.[25] When Suharto resigned in 1998, it left a political vacuum that inflamed local politics throughout the country.[26]
            The initial phases of the Poso conflict surrounded mayoral elections as Muslims and Christians each battled to get their favored candidate in position.[27] Street fights ensued, inflammatory graffiti littered the streets, and hundreds homes were burned.[28] The conflict continued in phases largely determined by which side was seeking reprisal.[29] After a group of alleged Christian ringleaders was sentenced to death in 2001, attacks on Muslims increased.[30] In stepped Laskar Jihad, a newly formed Muslim militia.[31] They were able to gain influence in the region because local Muslim communities has lost all faith in the security forces.[32] Their arrival in 2001 added several hundred experienced fighters to the Muslim ranks, and coincided with a spike in violence. [33] Jamaah Islamiyah (JI), Southeast Asia’s largest terrorist organization, had also infiltrated the region.[34]
d)    Sept 11, 2001 –the beginning of one war, the end of another
            Laskar Jihad's leader had fought alongside bin Laden in Afghanistan.[35] The Indonesian government long denied any link between Laskar Jihad and al Qaeda, but in December 2001 the head of Indonesian intelligence finally agreed that the two were linked.[36] JI also helped two of the September 11, 2001 hijackers and has confessed to plotting and carrying out attacks against Western targets, including the 2002 Bali bombings.[37]
            In the aftermath of the September 11th attacks, reports of the violence in Poso caught international attention.[38] The U.S. put pressure on the Indonesian government to put a stop to the conflict and eradicate the Islamic fundamentalist groups.[39] On December 20, 2001, Muslim and Christian leaders, accompanied by 4,000 military and police, signed the Malino Agreement.[40] It took another year for the fighting to officially stop, in fact sporadic attacks continue to this day.[41]
            The four years of fighting in Poso left between 1,000-2,500 dead, thousands more injured, hundreds of churches and mosques burned, and over 100,000 Internally Displaced People (IDPs).[42] Part of the reconciliation process includes resettling these IDPs who may claim land now occupied by other mobile citizens.[43] Part of the Malino Agreement included talks of returning property to ‘pre-conflict’ status.[44]
2)    Land & Natural Resource Rights in Indonesia
a)     Background
            Land disputes in Indonesia are consistently reported as the most frequent after general criminal disputes, the most difficult to resolve, and the most likely to trigger violence.[45] Ethnic/religious conflicts are reportedly low.[46] In Sulawesi, a 2006 World Bank survey found that 17.5% of reported cases were over land disputes, (Sulawesi was the only region who’s land disputes were higher than its criminal disputes), while only 3.4% were ethnic/religious conflicts.[47]
            The basis of modern Indonesian land law is Law Number 5 of 1960, also referred to as UUPA (Basic Agrarian Law Act).[48] It was created under President Soekarno and the Old Order, the first regime after independence.[49] The primary focus at the time was to protect Indonesian natural resources and local property from foreign influence so that Indonesian economic development could be fully cultivated and controlled from within.[50] This was due to awareness that the poverty of the majority of Indonesian people had its roots in an access to natural resources.[51]
            When Suharto became president in 1967 he upended those policies.[52] His natural resource management policies, under the New Order, are widely acknowledged as having planted the seeds of conflict in many areas of the country.[53] The New Order opened Indonesia to foreign capital investment and made foreign debts the prime source of development funding.[54] Development practices bluntly claimed poor people’s proprietary rights and access to natural resources.[55] Most significantly, in the 1980s the government classified over 75% of Indonesia’s total land area as State Forest.[56] Violence was used as the primary tool to impede those who demanded their proprietary rights.[57] During this time there were many “forced evictions” that disproportionately affected women.[58] The legacies of the New Order laws and policies encouraged unbridled commercial extraction of Indonesia’s natural resources.[59]
            The 1997 economic crisis forced President Suharto to step down amidst the international community’s growing awareness of human rights violations that were committed to defend the interests of private companies.[60] The Reform Era, which followed, is a clash between the ideologies of the two previous regimes.[61]  On one hand, the government issued a new law for Agrarian Reform (although dismissing it in practice).[62] On the other hand, the regimes in this era continued the New Order’s practice of accommodating foreign investors and debts, particularly by allowing the privatization of natural resources.[63]
b)    The Indonesian Constitution
            Article 33 of the Indonesian Constitution reflects the focus of the Old Order. It provides that “the land, water and their natural riches are controlled by the state and shall be used to the greatest benefit of the people.”[64] However, this provision has served as legal justification for sweeping state control.[65]
            Article 18 manifests the other side of a longstanding inherent tension in the Indonesian Constitution between state control and community-based rights.[66] In August 2000, it was amended to include “the state shall acknowledge and respect traditional societies along with their customary rights as long as these remain in existence and are in accordance with the societal development and the principles of the Unitary State of the Republic of Indonesia, and shall be regulated by law.”[67]
            Since Indonesia’s independence in 1945, this tension has been resolved almost always in favor of Article 33 and unbridled state control.[68] However, properly interpreted, both articles indicate that the state holds the land in an administrative capacity for the benefit of the people.[69]
c)     Present day context
            Although the second half of the 20th century had seen many of Indonesia’s people lose rights to their land, the government has concurrently taken great strides to address environmental legal reform.[70] It has introduced laws that specifically target strengthening local environmental management institutions.[71] The Indonesian Center for Environmental Law conducts training courses for members of the Indonesian judiciary in environmental law. The head of Indonesia’s Supreme Court has indicated to the High Court that he recommends only judges with this ICEL training be appointed to hear environmental cases.[72] Indonesia has also greatly diversified is environmental dispute resolution mechanisms. [73] What remains is for the average Indonesian citizen to be able to make use of these reforms.
3)    Access to Justice
a)     National, formal legal system
            Local awareness of the importance of justice and legal empowerment is getting stronger, yet access to the formal legal system for local community members remains rare.[74] In a 2001 survey, 56% of Indonesians were unable to give a single example of a right to which they were legally entitled; the percentage jumped to 66% for women, and 97% for those with no formal education.[75]
            Poor people’s access to the formal legal system is limited by inaccessible language, discrimination, corruption, and lengthy processes. [76] Indigenous people are consistently marginalized, uninformed, and even sometimes considered “illegal” squatters on land they have settled for generations.[77]
b)    Local, traditional justice system
            Non-state justice is the primary mode of dispute resolution in Indonesia.[78] Indonesians prefer to settle things locally.[79] Local customary law tribunals are well-established, but traditional community and religious leaders also practice arbitration and mediation.[80] Research suggests that for small intra-communal disputes, non-state justice operates rapidly and effectively.[81]  High satisfaction rates reflect this success.[82]
            But one of the main problems with the traditional, local justice system is that results are arbitrarily based on the decisions of “elites” and with the goal of ensuring village harmony.[83] Harmony is often equivalent to maintaining the status quo or social norms.[84] The results therefore are not always “just” for individuals, especially minorities or those underrepresented.[85] One of these categories is, of course, women.[86] Another problem is that local justice systems are not well connected with the formal legal system and also lack the resources to handle complex cases, or the “jurisdiction” over outside parties.[87] Many land disputes fall into these categories.[88]
4)    Recommendations
a)      Increasing access to justice –grassroots level
            Access to justice will not only provide citizens with an alternative to violence to air their grievances, but will also allow them to advocate for changes in policy at the national level to reflect their interests.[89] Grassroots programs working with communities can, and have, successfully generate demand for institutional change at the national level.[90] The participation and the inclusion of women’s organizations in the formal political peace process is crucial as they are generally the ones who work with, help, and understand people at the grassroots level.[91]
i)      Women’s empowerment
            The gender division of labor in Indonesia has changed - women are increasingly generating income for the family due to poverty and a lack of men’s mobility.[92] The killings of a large number of men in public spaces, including their farms, during and after the conflict has limited men’s mobility to carry out productive economic activities outside the home.[93] Women are also powerful actors during conflict.[94] They take on a variety of different roles to ensure their family’s survival.[95] They also take on roles as community organizers, distributing clothes, medical care, and other basic needs to victims.[96] In Central Sulawesi, they are particularly active in IDP camps.[97]  In the Poso conflict, this meant that women were able to point out that the conflict was not actually based on religion. Women from Muslim and Christian communities helped each other and disguised each other to escape raids during the conflict.[98] Such a connection with the realities of the conflict make women vital in the peace building process.
            For many people, women are considered better peace builders because they are seen as less threatening and more open to informal dialogue between Muslim and Christian communities through their daily activities in the marketplace and the community.[99] All of these activities strengthen their understanding of community members needs and realities, as well as establish their connections and influence within the community.[100]  Although women’s political participation is still limited, it seems to be increasing, especially in the village political arena.[101] Some women have become heads of the villages, neighborhoods and members of village councils, in part as a result of their peace activism and humanitarian work.[102] Yet, up until this point, these roles are mostly ‘invisible’ as women have generally been overlooked and marginalized in the context of the formal peace-building processes.[103]
b)     Capacity building
            Capacity building should continue at both the national and local levels, but with an increased focus on integrating women and getting them into decision-making positions.[104] The emergence of women in conflict and peace-related issues is a new phenomenon in Poso and surrounding areas.[105] Generally these women have limited education, knowledge, organizational experience and leadership skills.[106] Although many of the female peace activists in Poso were university student activists or were actively engaged in the NGO activities before the conflict, the older generation is less educated.[107] Some have not completed high school and others have only finished elementary school.[108] A lack of education prevents women’s organizations from understanding their rights or how to enforce them, from engaging on constructive development, and from accessing established networks.[109]
            Women’s groups have identified a need for managerial and leadership skills, group and community organization skills, fundraising skills, networking skills, communication, information and dissemination skills including policy advocacy, campaigning, lobbying, public speaking and presentation, monitoring and evaluation skills, negotiation, mediation and conflict resolution, and women’s political participation.[110]
            Since women are generally not familiar with formal debate, dialogue and discussion due to their marginal position in the decision-making and formal peace processes, an affirmative action policy would help efforts in strengthening women’s capacity.[111] This includes facilitating women’s participation in seminars, workshops and conferences at the local, national, and international level. Graduate school scholarship assistance would be beneficial, as well as long-term, sustainable technical and financial support for women’s organizations. [112]
c)     An expanding legal field –barefoot lawyering
            There are many Indonesian legal aid groups that have set up outposts, or posko[113], around the country to provide “barefoot lawyering” –educating rural citizens on the basics of the Indonesian legal system, connecting them to resources, and also representing individuals or communities in bringing suit.[114] But studies have shown that backing from organizations, individuals, or the general international community often influence cases’ success.[115] A place exists, and continues to grow, for lawyers from the international community to go do some non-traditional lawyering. Sharing of skills and resources, educational tools, “witnessing” or accompanying cases, and advocacy –representing individuals or communities at higher levels or connecting them with available resources –are strong “soft skills” for many lawyers and are in high demand by marginalized populations in Indonesia and other developing countries.
Conclusion
            Although Poso today is relatively peaceful, developing means for community members to address their environmental and other legal concerns is critical in maintaining peace in the future. Low economic growth and unemployment can make post-conflict areas more prone to slipping back into conflict.[116] Particularly for young men, helping them attain a stake in the local economy is a critical factor for peace as they are the most susceptible part of society to the frustration and resentment that can lead to violence.[117] JI and other fundamentalists groups continue to recruit in Central Sulawesi, sending new students to South Asia and elsewhere for training. A steady stream of Indonesians travel to India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh every year for training, and Indonesian jihadists have well-established contacts there.[118]
            Economic growth in Indonesia is strongly connected to access to natural resources.[119] It is critically important that local communities have access to the benefits brought by foreign investors in these natural resources, and that their concerns are part of the decision making process. This bridge will be forged largely by a well-integrated legal system that even the most marginalized can access. Peace in Poso, and in the rest of the world depends on it.


[1] See, e.g., Center for Humanitarian Dialogue, Conflict Management Strategies in Indonesia: Learning from the Poso Experience (2009) [hereinafter HD Centre].
[2] Id.
[3] See, e.g.,Which Way to the War (Spotted Frog Productions 2009).
[4] See, e.g., Gogali, Lian, The Power to Rebuild. Inside Indonesia 105 (2011).
[5] See, e.g., The World Bank, A Framework for Strengthening Access to Justice in Indonesia (2007)
[6] See, e.g., Int’l Crisis Group, ICG Asia Report No. 74, Indonesia Backgrounder: Jihad in Central Sulawesi (2004); Id. at 43.
[7] Lorraine V. Aragon, Can Central Sulawesi Christians and Muslims Get Along? An Analysis of Indonesian Regional Conflict, 63 Antropologi Indonesia 53, 54 (2000).
[8] Id.
[9] Id. at 56-58.
[10] Id. at 56.
[11] Id. at 54.
[12] Id. at 57.
[13] Lorraine V. Aragon, Waiting for Peace in Poso, 70 Inside Indonesia (2002).
[14] Id.
[15] Aragon, supra note 7, at 58.
[16] Aragon, supra note 13.
[17] Id.
[18] Aragon, supra note 7, at 57.
[19] Id.
[20] Id.
[21] Legal Empowerment of the Poor: Lessons Learned from Indonesia, 22, 27 (Patra M. Zen & Restu Mahyuni, eds., Matt Zurtrassen et al. trans., 2007) [hereinafter Legal Empowerment].
[22] Aragon, supra note 7, at 57-58.
[23] Id. at 60.
[24] Id.
[25] Id.
[26] Id.
[27] Id.
[28] Id.
[29] See generally Human Rights Watch, Vol. 14, No. 9 (C), Breakdown: Four Years of Communal Violence in Central Sulawesi (2002) [hereinafter HRW] (detailing stages of the conflict).
[30] Which Way to the War, supra note 3.
[31] HRW, supra note 29, at 10, 23.
[32] Id. at 2, 11.
[33] Id. at 10-12.
[34] Sidney Jones, Briefing for the New President: The Terrorist Threat in Indonesia and Southeast Asia, 618 Annals Am. Acad. Pol. & Soc. Sci. 69 (2008).
[35] HRW, supra note 29, at 12-13.
[36] Id. at 10-13; Bruce Vaughn et al., Cong. Research Serv., RL34194, Terrorism in Southeast Asia 5-6 (2009).
[37] Vaughn, supra note 36, at 8.
[38] HRW, supra note 29, at 12, 28.
[39] See generally Vaughn, supra note 36.
[40] HRW, supra note 29, at 29-31.
[41] Id. at 3-4.
[42] Id. at 9, 38-40.
[43] Aragon, supra note 13.
[44] Id.
[45] See, e.g., Karrie McLaughlin & Ari Perdana, Conflict and Dispute Resolution in Indonesia (2010).
[46] Id. at 8.
[47] Id.
[48] Legal Empowerment, supra note 21, at 22.
[49] Id. at 21-22.
[50] Id. at 21.
[51] Id.
[52] Id. at 25-29.
[53] See, e.g., Nick Mawdsley et al., Building Sustainable Peace: Local Economic Development, Natural Resources and Livelihoods North Maluku, Maluku and Central Sulawesi 5 (2005).
[54] Legal Empowerment, supra note 21, at 34.
[55] Id.
[56] Daniel Barstow Magraw & Lauren Baker, Globalization, Communities and Human Rights: Community Based Property Rights and Prior Informed Consent, 35 Denv. J. Int’l L. & Pol’y 413 (2007).
[57] Legal Empowerment, supra note 21, at 34.
[58] Id. at 71.
[59] Owen Lynch & Emily Harwell, Ctr. for Int’l Envtl. L., Whose Natural Resources? Whose Common Good? Towards a New Paradigm of Environmental Justice and the National Interest in Indonesia 71 (2002).
[60] Legal Empowerment, supra note 21, at 35.
[61] Legal Empowerment, supra note 21, at 34.
[62] Id. at 29.
[63] Id. at 18.
[64] The 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, art. 33 (3).
[65] Lynch, supra note 59, at 143.
[66] Id.
[67] The 1945 Const. of the Republic of Indonesia, art. 18B (2) (amended 2000).
[68] Lynch, supra note 59, at 143.
[69] Lynch, supra note 59, at xxxii; Legal Empowerment, supra note 21, at 22-23.
[70] See, e.g., Lynch, supra note 59.
[71] Id.
[72] The World Bank, Investing in a More Sustainable Indonesia 27 pg.? (2009).
[73] See generally David Nicholson, Environmental Dispute Resolution in Indonesia (2009); Environmental Law in Development (Michael Faure & Nicole Niessen eds. 2006).
[74] See, e.g. Legal Empowerment, supra note 21, at 3.
[75] The World Bank, A Framework for Strengthening Access to Justice in Indonesia, 5-6 (2007) [hereinafter framework].
[76] Legal Empowerment, supra note 21, at 5.
[77] Lynch, supra note 59, at 43.
[78] Framework, supra note 59, at 1.
[79] Andrea Woodhouse et al.,Village Justice in Indonesia Case Studies on Access to Justice, Village Democracy, and Governance 26 (2004).
[80] World Bank Indon., Forging the Middle Ground: Engaging Non-state Justice in Indonesia, at x. (2008) [hereinafter Forging].
[81] Id. at ix.
[82] Id.
[83] E.g., Framework, supra note 59, at 9.
[84] Woodhouse, supra note 79, at iv-v.
[85] E.g., McLaughlin, supra note 45; Matthew Zurstrassen, Indonesia’s Revitalization of Legal Aid (RLA) Program: Strengthening Legal Services for the Poor, 1 Just. for the Poor (2007).
[86] Forging, supra note 80, at 22.
[87] See, e.g., Woodhouse, supra note 79.
[88] E.g., Zurstrassen, supra note 85; Forging, supra note 80.
[89] See, e.g., U.N.Dev.Prog. Indon., Legal Empowerment and Assistance for the Disadvantaged Project (LEAD), National Strategy on Access to Justice (2009).
[90] Cate Sumner et al., Increasing Access to Justice for Women, the Poor, and Those Living in Remote Areas: An Indonesian Case Study, 6 Just. for the Poor (2011).
[91] Endah Trista Agustiana & Maria Pakpahan, Women and Peace-Building Central Sulawesi and North Maluku, 27 (2004).
[92] Id. at 9.
[93] Id.
[94] Id.
[95] Id.
[96] Id. at 5.
[97] Id.
[98] Interview with Lian Gogali, Founder, Inst. Mosintuwu, in Bali, Indon. (July 2011).
[99] Agustiana, supra note 91, at 29; HD Centre, supra note 1.
[100] Agustiana, supra note 91.
[101] Id. at 4.
[102] Id.
[103] Id.
[104] E.g., Id.
[105] Id. at 28.
[106] Id.
[107] Id. at 19.
[108] Id.
[109] Id. at 28.
[110] Id. at 29.
[111] Id. at 30.
[112] Id. at 35.
[113] Zurstrassen, supra note 85.
[114] See Legal Empowerment, supra note 21; Sumner, supra note 90; Woodhouse, supra note 79, at 94-98; for a few of the many success stories of these initiatives.
[115] Woodhouse, supra note 79, at 63-64.
[116] E.g. Aragon, supra note 7, at 59.
[117] Mawdsley, supra note 53, at 6.
[118] Sidney Jones, Briefing for the New President: The Terrorist Threat in Indonesia and Southeast Asia, 618 Annals Am. Acad. Pol. & Soc. Sci. 69, 70 (2008).
[119] E.g., Legal Empowerment, supra note 21 at 18, 35.

Let the Last Wisps of Idealism Wither by the Banks of Lake Poso


**This was a 'Reflective Journal' assignment, where we were also supposed to make our definition of true success.**

(*DISCLAIMER: I don't know anything yet for my definition of True Success. The following, and most of my current personal/professional focus, is to find out what it is.*)
        
“3,000 families own Indonesia.” I decided on my way out to try a little of one of my old favorite skills –sticking my nose where it doesn’t belong, on behalf of others. I used to be good at it. Senegalese officials, perhaps because I guaranteed them a good laugh, never said no when I showed up at their offices demanding they answer my questions or pay attention to my tiny village hundreds of miles away.  I think one of my proudest moments was, after riding across half the country in the bleaching sun on dusty red roads on a broke-down motorbike (we found out after –the bike was not meant for two –my weight on the back led to approximately 10 flat tires, among other problems), my village counterpart and I showed up in the doorway of the Minister of Education. “My village wants to build a middle school.” I announced in my staged haughty-American way. The Minister, although not promising us a school at that moment (mission –failed) did take the time to explain to Laity Baidjan, my counterpart, wide-eyed and speechless, the exact process my village needed to take to apply for a school. Believe it or not, we had to come all the way to the Minister of Education to get a straight answer. Still, it felt so strange sitting there in our patchwork fancy clothes that smelled of sweat and were a tinge more orange then they were originally. But it was also an intensely proud moment –my shamelessness had made the Minister of Education take time, while a line of others waited outside his door, to address Laity as a person, to recognize the needs of the village I had lived in.

This seems to be a non-transferable skill. Or at least, one that doesn’t work in Indonesia. Of course, my appointments were a bit different than they were in Senegal. I had made use of an old contact to connect with some ex-pat lawyers and business people in Jakarta. So none of them were Indonesian. Well, one was half. But still, Indonesia has a way of carrying out all its daily activities while the government officials remain shrouded in mystery. It’s true –I hadn’t heard it put into a number –but a small number of Indonesian families –the Jakarta elite –control not only the capital but everything else in the country. I had two fundamental questions for my contacts in Jakarta –“Is there any order underlying the chaos of the legal system?”, and, “What advice should I give to the people in Peura?” My first contact answered the two questions in one –“Just stay out of the court system. Once you get it in the courts, you lost.”

I was speaking to the country head of a certain well-known multinational business (that may or not have had a large hand in the global financial crisis.) After he made this statement, both him and the company’s senior consultant began showering me with stories of how they had dealt with clients who had managed to get them into the court system. They were both a bit giddy –one thing about ex-pats that I rely on is they are never reluctant to submerge visitors into the sea of their daily experience. They perhaps get tired of recycling the same stories to a small group of people, who are having similar experiences themselves, and who won’t laugh in the same way at the irony. So I found myself addressing this figure –who I had previously only known through uber-formal and respectful emails that had to be edited 10,000 times before my boss would press send –in the only way I knew how. I have a problem socializing with business people –especially the higher they get up the food chain. I am a naturally crude person, I spent the first 17 years of my life in a box (and so lack a lot of cultural/social knowledge), I don’t know anything about business, except quips I have picked up from the “other side” (i.e. –business is the devil.) So I can either sit there silently and politely –my chosen strategy for the two years I worked at my last job –or, if I was forced to have a personality, I would swallow a giant lump in my throat, try not to pay attention to my instantly overactive sweat glands, and open the floodgates to the channel of my brain.

“So…basically your business is just a bunch of glorified bargaining?” I asked hesitantly, but with confidence. Phew –they laughed as if that was the right thing to say. But then I couldn’t help myself –I kept on going. “How do you do it?” (solemn stares), “I mean, you guys are like warriors,” (hearty laughter), “How do you live in a world where everything is suspended? Where there’s no solid ground?” I felt as if I was being too invasive, too informal, but mostly, too depressing. Mr. B’s eyes fell out of contact as he explained, “Well, here, there are no rules. So it works both ways. You can go outside, and cross the street whenever and wherever you want, and people will make room for you.” He was really focused on the crossing the street aspect, but also vaguely referred to Indonesia as a communal society whereas in the West you can wither by the wayside and no one will notice or come to help. I found out later that Mr. B came from South Africa (in another mortifying moment –I guessed that he was Australian), and his family had apparently had a rough go of it. So to him, Indonesia perhaps was more ordered, less chaotic. And perhaps the tint of darkness that I couldn’t help but notice in every interaction didn’t even register on his radar. Now I feel bad that I asked him those questions.

But as far as self-reflection on this experience, I think perhaps what could have saved me from making a hard-working, well respected executive feel bad about his life decisions would have been an earlier realization about what type of person I am. I left that meeting feeling like “What’s wrong with me? Why am I so focused on the negative? Why am I not able to focus on the beautiful things about this country?” But then I thought of the many conversations I had with fellow law students before I left, and will probably continue to have when I get back. To them, working in Indonesia sounds exotic and strange –I get any number of reactions along the lines of “Wow, that is so interesting/exciting,” “It’s such a great thing that you’re doing,” “What a great experience!” But many of these people would never consider basing their life in Indonesia. So perhaps I am somewhere in the middle. But, my worst fear is that perhaps I have just been on the wrong track.

I don’t want to reflect too much on my actual experience this summer, since I did enough of that in the blogs and on the discussion board. I also hesitate to reorient my life based on what is, of course, a unique experience. But I am a bit of a handmaiden to fate, and I came here this summer to answer certain questions. So not only can I not help but interpret my experiences in order to answer these questions, but I have some faith that my experiences were the universe’s way of unfolding the next leg of my journey. Is this the proper way of looking at law school? It is how I have interpreted my life so far, and so either I allow law school to change me or I just try to apply my unconventional way of thinking to this experience I voluntarily engaged in despite the best advice of my trusted circle.

Perhaps in hindsight I will remember the good more clearly, and will be enticed to return. But right now, I kind of dread going back to school and facing the inevitable question –“Oh my God, was Indonesia so awesome?” Because the biggest impression that stands out in my mind right now is how pervasively frustrating it was to deal with the dark and mysterious nature of a people raised in a conflict and post-conflict society. Of a people bred on various shades of colonialism. Of a people in a society that it would take me a lifetime to understand. This is paired with the reality that –faced with this situation in the community –much of my summer was spent face to face with my computer, reading about perhaps even more depressing realities (conflict, domestic violence, a disastrous and corrupt legal system).

There are many questions that run along side this major one (i.e., maybe I feel this way because I wasn’t working in the right place, with the right people, with the right support, etc.) –but after this summer I have to ask myself  -“Is this the right place for me?” Yes, this question is very similar to the one I was asking at the beginning of the summer -“Is a job like this the best fit for my skills and interests?,” - but it is different in a number of ways. First of all, I don’t think I should hold myself responsible anymore for really meaning “Westerners” in the place of “me.” No matter what my conclusion on that question, which probably will take me a lifetime to answer, I don’t have to feel like answering it is the only way I can move forward in my career. The reality of this way of thinking is playing itself out right now –I am 29 and have yet to find direction. I can’t wait until I figure out the answer to this question to move forward –or else I never will. So, perhaps Mr. B and others are able to work in Indonesia, I no longer need to try to fit this into my framework of understanding my place in the world. I no longer have to reflect on their answers as they apply to my life. I essentially didn’t need to ask them the questions I did, because, in order to keep things simple and professional, I can simply tell myself that these people are different from me. Let them answer the bigger questions on their own, and me on my own, but we don’t need to answer them together. We don’t need to decide if Westerners belong in Indonesia in order for me to chose my career path. I only have to decide if I belong there. Even if my skills and interests match up, I personally have to be happy in a place or I am not going to do anyone any good. Although I have raged against this conclusion formerly, living the experience of being in a place where I am not happy has shown me that no matter how I try to perfect my ideals, I am in the end human, and can only work to my full capacity when I am happy. So, for the sake of the work I want to do for the world, I need to be “enlightendly selfish.”

So first, I have changed the question. But second, I have at least a loose answer to my original question. Or, I have suspended it. Perhaps later in life, a turn will happen that will allow me to reconsider. People have advised me that it would be a tragedy to answer this question so definitively based on my experience this summer. But, my experience this summer has fit in nicely with my previous experience, and since I was asking the question, I feel that I have to accept the answer at this point and proceed accordingly. No. This is not the right place for my skills and interests. Let’s say I put 100% effort into my externship this summer. 10% of it, at least, unfortunately, was spent dealing with the online portion of this class, although half of that was me overdoing it with my blogs and discussion boards, so it was a bit of a personal decision to reflect and keep myself sane. So who knows if I would have spent that time in some other way (i.e writing on my own or processing with others) but at least 10% of my energy was not applied directly to the work I was doing. I think, in the future, if I was doing a similar externship, I wouldn’t want to spend that much of my time disengaged.

I would say another 40% of my energy was spent dealing with interpersonal conflicts/politics. This is the part that is most significant for me. Granted, in any job, a vast amount of your energy will probably be spent dealing with “people problems.” But as I tried to explain to my co-workers this summer, if you are working within your own culture, either this entire 40% is applied directly to dealing with the interpersonal problem, or perhaps you would spend less than 40% of your energy on it. This summer, I felt like everywhere I turned I dealt with pervasive people problems, but I was often at a loss to interpret them or to do anything about it. Language barriers, cultural barriers, as well as the fact that 2 months is too short to get to know any person well enough to be able to effectively manage their personality (this would happen anywhere but is compounded by language and cultural barriers abroad) meant I spent most of my time spinning my wheels, asking questions, or too scared to act.

Additionally, my ethics regarding the level of Western influence over developing countries has gone through a series of progressions. Lets just start with colonization/missionaries: not a good idea. Then we moved into the IMF/World Bank strict “get your act together” policies: also didn’t work. Then we moved more into a development model –Western organizations working in developing countries, somewhat side-by-side, but assessing the situation from a Western viewpoint and prescribing the right “path” towards development. I think I stepped in somewhere at this point in the development-development timeline. But my time in the Peace Corps showed me that prescriptions from Westerners/outsiders, or even the national government (most of which had never actually been to the places they were making the prescriptions for) was the entirely wrong model. The only thing that would work is a grassroots-initiated initiative. Around this time I decided to go to law school. I understood the only proper place for myself was as an advocate. The community would tell me what they wanted to do, and I would use my Westernity (comprising education, opportunity, connections, etc.) to help them do it.

I set out this summer with this model in mind. However, there are two roadblocks. One is, its never that simple. People come to me with lots of different ideas, helping them achieve all of them is not possible. I can’t help but give them advice on which are the most feasible, not only for practicalities sake, but because I am a person operating from my own experiences and some ideas sound better than others, some ideas sound damn near impossible. But similarly, as an educated and somewhat experienced individual, I can’t help but exert at least a tiny bit of influence over the direction people are taking. And, even providing this service I think in the end inhibits people. The Poso conflict ended 8 years ago, yet I got the sense this summer that people are just sitting there waiting for NGOs to come in and help them recover and reconstruct their society. This is the typical result that demonstrates the failure of development models: dependency theory. If there are always outsiders in there trying to commandeer the solution to the problem, people never develop their own initiative. The intense initiative that’s needed for revolutionary change.

Take the Indonesian legal system. It is VASTLY fucked up (please pardon my language, but there is no other way to express how bad it is.) Legal inflation, corruption, the underlying problem of either making a unified legal system for thousands of different peoples, or finding some way to string together a multitude of systems, fitting the customary and formal legal systems together. Many suggest a complete overhaul –and I, with my limited knowledge, frustrated with the inability to go forward because the legal system is perhaps simply un-understandable, can’t help but agree at this point. If legal reform isn’t hard enough, Indonesia also needs to convince its officials to buy into it: to apply the laws, to enforce them, to not be corrupt. I can’t see where my place could be in this sea of disaster. Perhaps I could sit beside the judges and encourage them not to be corrupt, but I think this needs to come from Indonesian’s themselves. Perhaps I could advise lawmakers about how to make the system work, but it seems like those with the best knowledge of this would be Indonesians. The time it would take an outsider to gather the information about all the different cultures, legal history, current legal operation, etc. would be in a sense reinventing the wheel. Indonesia’s legal problems are so unique it would be difficult for an outsider to apply their knowledge to the Indonesian situation. In fact, it might end up leading right back to the original trap: ideas prescribed from outside are not only vulnerable to not being the right fit, but deprive the Indonesian people from the intense national debate that needs to happen to decide, together, what is best for them. Thinking back to the legal debates we learned about in our Constitutional Law class, the intricate detail that was debated, fiercely, by our founding legal scholars, it seems crazy that a country would be formed without this process. Marshall, Adams, etc. –their entire lives were dedicated to whatever relatively tiny legal cause was currently on the table. I don’t think the concept of personal and professional separation existed for them. That is a luxury we are now able to enjoy. But I am thinking about how in all the capstone cases that decided relatively minute details of what the word “commerce” means, and how the various lawyers would have to get on horseback and ride out to discuss the meanings up for debate with their constituents. How many years did this process go on for? Our country, as a group, decided, over a long period of time, every concept that exists in our founding laws. People died over it. People gave up their entire lives for it. The thing that always comes through for me reading about that time was people’s dedication. But they were coming relatively freshly off the heels of persecution, they had already risked their lives to travel across the ocean into the unknown in hopes of a better life. (Sometimes I wonder if the way our country was founded makes it the only possible place for a functional democracy.) I think it is that process that makes people committed to their laws. And I think outsider influence in developing countries hampers people from riling up the dedication that is needed for them to form their own legal systems. I don’t pity them the process –it makes me incredibly thankful for the work our founding fathers did for us. But, it seems to be the only way.

So, now there is nothing left as far as my place in developing countries. Perhaps later in my career I will discover it, but I think for now I have made the choice to pursue more of a policy angle. Then, at least, my daily life at work would be working within my own or a similar culture. So I wouldn’t have to spend this extra time, which for entire days/weeks of the summer was sometimes all-pervasive, figuring out the ropes of another system. Perhaps this initial viewpoint is similarly idealistic, but I think I need to try it out. Of course, I instantly meet another road block: one of my personal and professional ethics is I never want to be sitting at some air-conditioned desk in the capital of some country (or, God forbid, Washington, D.C.) writing policy for a people that I have never even met. But, there must be some niche in the middle. I am going to set out to find it. What I think I have managed to chip off of my too-broad and undefined career aspirations is “direct service” grassroots work. I no longer think I want to be based in the jungle, living with the people. Although this is an element that I have to deal with on a very personal level, I think my career experience thus far has shown me, time and again, that this type of work does not allow me to be as effective as I could be. Personally, I must set sail the Viking funeral of my college self –the Jaime that was committed to becoming a Jesus figure –to making personal sacrifices, to shoulder a bit of the burden of the world to make it a better place.

I just had dinner with a friend from high school last night and was talking about just this, and she was disappointed. She pointed out how I have always loved and excelled at learning languages and integrating into other cultures, and so it would be a shame to let this go. I agree. So perhaps another element to this new career track, or maybe even a separate track to consider simultaneously, is to instead focus in on one culture and language and get really good at it, to avoid the 100/40% dilemma. The most obvious for me is somewhere in the Middle East. Do I want to learn Farsi and work in Afghanistan? Will Afghanistan be intricately tied to our own national fate for the rest of my lifetime, or is it something that will fade and therefore make my skills obsolete? Should I just learn Arabic so my skills will be more transferable in the Middle East? Am I too old to take on a new language, especially Arabic? Where am I going to find the time to learn it? But most importantly, am I brave enough to confront the Middle East –a place both frightening to me, but also where my own personal emotions are bound to get tied up? Do I need a separation of personal and professional space, or have I just been avoiding the true goal this entire time? Is “Middle Eastern” (I am aware, this is entirely too big of a generalization), or any of the Middle Eastern countries, a good fit for me? How will I work as a woman in such a patriarchal society? How will I integrate my current despisal of religion into a society formed by it? At the very least, at this point, I need to start investigating the answers to these questions.

The other option is Senegal, where I both excel at the language and know a lot about the culture. But somehow Senegal seems too limited to me. Not only is it just one country with its own unique problems, but development is not my end goal. Development to end poverty, to end lack of options, to end lack of education, which I think are the biggest contributors to global violence. So I don’t think I would get personal satisfaction from working in Senegal. Put simply, I don’t think it’s my calling. Though it is a shame to let those skills, which are relatively rare in the world, go to waste.

I could think of another country/language/culture to focus on, but at this point, I think if I don’t chose the Middle East or Senegal, I might rather just stay at home and work on policy. A way to deal with the policy from afar problem would be to work on American policy that affects other countries. Like, the law that governs how corporations have to negotiate with “locals” when operating in other countries. I want to take a class on this (what is it?) to explore that option. The other obvious area is foreign policy/national security, though my explorations in this field in the past have led me to conclude that only the best and the brightest get these positions, (correct me if I am wrong), so I might be wasting my time pursuing this angle? And then of course is international law. I am so excited to take International Human Rights Law and International Criminal Law this semester to learn more about this field. The stereotypical, and perhaps misguided, complaint that comes hand in hand with this is that international laws are basically “best practices” guidelines and don’t mean anything in reality. And my experience this summer added another example to confirm this conclusion. Indonesia is part of about a bagillion international agreements about gender equality, women’s rights, violence against women, etc. And they report every year to the UN or whatever commission on their progression in enforcing these agreements. I read through the transcripts, and they are pathetic. It must be an embarrassment for the UN or whatever commissions to even print these transcripts as they are blaring examples of their inefficiency: they go through the checklist of goals, Indonesia responds that it has made minimal efforts to meet any of them, or avoids responding all together, and they plan to meet up again in 5 years. But maybe a good professional goal would be taking international legal agencies one step closer to being more effective?

I also might want to pursue a bit of Native American law, not only to help our own indigenous people, but to work on a model that truly respects indigenous people. I find it funny that helping indigenous people abroad is a trendy career option, yet our own indigenous people suffer from some of the worst legal injustices around. Though this risks falling into the same trap of prescription from abroad, it could at least provide an example of one system that has worked?

Am I thinking about my career to broadly/generally/idealistically? I think I am trying to pin down the overall roadmap before I get down to the details, but perhaps that is the opposite approach. I should just throw myself into a job that seems relatively related, where I can imagine going to work every day and enjoying it, and build up the big picture from there?

Anyway, this is where my experience this summer has taken me. There are a couple of different angles I want to investigate at this point, a couple I want to lay to rest for a while. I have to admit, back to the new question -“Is this the right place for me?” that I am excited by the idea of a career option that will allow me to stay at home, not be alone, eat normal food (for me!), and pursue a bit more of a “normal” career that will perhaps –gasp! –allow me to make some money! I hope that these feelings, which intensify as I get older and have started thinking about family –do not corrupt my thinking too much. That would be another sell-out blow to my college self.

All of this makes me ask –why do I feel so dedicated to it? There are major underlying personal motivations, which I have to take some time to ask myself if I am ready/willing to let go of. Rationally, I know that it could end up in such a disaster if I continue to make career decisions based on personal motivations. But on the other hand, I feel like the best careers are made this way. And, I also don’t understand how you could make career decisions otherwise. (Unless for money, for power, etc., and I’m not willing to go there!) Sometimes I try to think about what I would enjoy, but this seems to abstract for me, and it seems like the only way I could find the answer was by trying a bunch of different jobs until I find one I like. It seems, at 29, that the experimental time has passed for that. I spent my window of opportunity otherwise. But, I feel law school has given me a fresh chance in this regard. I am being trained in a special skill –so I could wash out all other career options and just focus on those offered within the legal field. And, since at this age I have a good sense of my ethics and what I do/do not enjoy, I might actually be able to experiment around enough in law school and in a couple of years after to find something I enjoy. So I’d like to work for a firm, a judge, a corporation, etc. to see if those are something I would like. Could I possibly like trial law? The idea of letting my personal baggage set sail, finding something I enjoy and don’t just feel obligated to, and actually making enough money to support myself, sounds incredibly refreshing and wonderful. But then the thoughts start creeping in that I am betraying myself.

Why do I feel so dedicated to my college self? College is such a pure time. I think it is the time when the weight of the world finally settles on us. The world holds itself in a giant net, and from when we are born, it slowly lets itself down bit by bit, allowing us to feel its weight. College is such a beautiful moment because we graduate from childhood –from fully realizing the extent of ourselves –filling out our own form. We are a pure form of ourselves –not yet tainted by outside influences (i.e., the need to make money, provide for others, do something meaningful for society, etc.) –and so its easier to trust our judgment as emanating from who we really are and what we really want. But at the same time, we get our first glimpse of the world as it really is. I feel like there is a lot to trust in that judgment. We recognize things that are fucked up, and things that are good. We judge things with a simple sense of right and wrong. We line ourselves up, often forcefully, with causes that ring deeply within us. With this foundation, we set out upon the world to find our place in it. We are barraged with images from every level of society and from the people around us. We are manipulated by our needs and the needs of others. It just seems obvious to me, at least in regards to my own personal journey, that I want to trust the decisions I made before life forced me to alter them. To trust my original judgment of what was good and bad in the world and do my best to accommodate reality, but stay true to them.

Perhaps this is misguided. And perhaps this is the biggest question I have to tackle to move forward effectively in my career.